O’s Outline 2026: Build Your Best Roster & Lineup
Now entering the AlonsO’s era, the vibes are high in Birdland. It’s been cold in Baltimore, but the hot stove is BURNING and hope springs eternal. We’re all thinking the same thing, what do the O’s have left to do to finally bring a championship back home in 2026?
Here’s a fun mega-thread to exercise your inner armchair GM and Manager. I want to hear, what signings and trades do we still need to make this offseason? We have the resources for one more big signing + a major trade. What projected 26-man roster would those moves leave us with? And what would our best Opening Day lineup be?
I’ll go first —
Free Agency:
FA Plan A: Sign Tatsuya Imai (28)
7yrs/$161MM w/ opt-out after 2yrs + $25MM posting fee
Total max investment = 7yrs/$186MM
- This is the guy I want to sign long-term for 4 reasons: Age, ceiling, health, and no QO attached. Plus, pairing a potential Japanese superstar w/ Alonso as our big acquisitions could generate some next-level buzz. While an NPB player having MLB success is never a sure thing, the pipeline has been particularly strong recently and every other FA pitcher is over 30 and has a major red flag. Valdez - age + character, Suarez - back issues + avg velo, King - only two years as a starter + health.
FA Plan B: Sign Zac Gallen (30)
4yrs/$88MM w/ vesting option for 5th yr/$24MM
Total max investment = 5yrs, $112MM
- Pros: a workhorse who has only finished a season under 121 IP in his shortened rookie and COVID years. Has had dominant stretches in recent history, and has been to the World Series. Young enough, durable enough, and smart enough of a pitcher to lead a staff for the next 4 years. Bonus fun fact, I’ve heard he expected to be drafted by the O’s in 2016, but we selected Cody Sedlock instead. Hope there’s no grudges held!
- Cons: QO-attached after the most brutal stretch of his career in the first half of 2025 paired with a declining strikeout rate and a boom in HRs allowed. But these cons are why he’s not a $200mil pitcher right now. This could either be a quickly-aging pricey pitcher on the decline, or the steal of the offseason. Trade Plan A:
Acquire SP Pablo Lopez (30) from MIN for
1B Coby Mayo, P Esteban Mejia, P Jauron Watts-Brown, P Braxton Bragg (IL)
- The Twins say they’re holding onto their big 3 trade chips in Lopez, Ryan, and Buxton in hopes to retool, but is that ill-advised? The AL Central is always up for grabs, but DET is the clear favorite, CLE always finds a way, and KC is a pesky team with quality pitching. A Wild Card is unlikely with a big battle for the AL East brewing. Joe Ryan may be out of reach, but make a strong offer to the Twinkies for their most likely to be traded asset in Lopez that brings them current + future potential, plus salary relief of his remaining 2yrs/$43MM contract. Lopez had a down year due to injury but performed well when healthy. Hasn’t had an ERA+ below 103 or WHIP above 1.192 this decade. Trade Plan B:
Acquire SP Edward Cabrera (28) from MIA
For 1B Coby Mayo, C/OF Ike Irish, P Michael Forret, SS/2B Cobb Hightower (+ Comp Balance A Pick if needed to seal deal)
- A comparable package as for Lopez, but the Marlins always need offense in their system, so we sacrifice there to retain a little more organizational pitching depth. I am not as high as most on Cabrera because his price will be high while he’s only topped 100 IP once, and sounds like a TJ ticking time-bomb. I can’t help but feel like we just gave up on a similar profile pitcher in Grayson Rodriguez. But all pitchers are risks. The stuff is there, he offers the most years of control, and if healthy Cabrera will help us win now.
Trade Plan C:
Acquire SP MacKenzie Gore (27) from WSH
For 1B Coby Mayo, OF Nate George, P Esteban Mejia, P Keeler Morfe
- This is plan C because I expect the cost to be highest while Gore has the least consistent performance history and a year less control than Cabrera, but he is a high ceiling LHP. Also of note, we’ve never traded with the Nats. Would our cost be even higher than another team’s?
These moves leave us with the following ideal 26-man roster (please stay healthy) and primary lineup:
1. Westy 3B (R) 2. Gunnar SS (L) 3. Alonso 1B (R) 4. Ward LF (R) 5. Basallo DH/C (L) 6. Beavers/O’Neill RF (L/R) 7. Adley C/DH (S) 8. Cowser CF (L) 9. Holliday 2B (L)
A few notes here; Westy could be an incredible table setter atop our lineup, as he has some of the best ABs and plate approach in general on the team. He’s also fast but does not run himself into outs like Holliday has. Holliday may be the dynamic leadoff guy one day, but for now I’m dropping him down to the bottom of the lineup.
If Westy isn’t healthy, give Gunnar the lead-off spot. Best player gets the most ABs.
Alonso at 3 is the spot, don’t push him any farther down your lineup.
The shocker here might be Basallo at 5, but I’m banking on him living up to his potential, because when he makes contact the crack of the bat is comparable to only Ohtani and Judge.
I’m assuming we’re going to run with a Beavers/O’Neill platoon in RF until General Soreness shows up, at which point hopefully Beavers can continue his success from his cup of coffee last season.
Adley at 7? Yeah, show us that you can produce again before we give you crucial ABs at the top of the order, we can’t afford to waste them. This is the most balanced our lineup can be with no more than 2 same-sided hitters consecutively, neutralizing the other team’s L/R match-up ability.
Bench:
10. Beavers/O’Neill (COF), 11. Jackson (INF/COF), 12. Tavares/Bradfield (CF), 13. Kjerstad (1B/COF)/Back-up SS/Back-up C
I’m hoping Bradfield comes up before the end of the year and can be a speed/defense weapon in the playoffs. The last position spot is a toss up, as Kjerstad is a complete unknown at this point, we lack a true SS back-up (not super critical since we have flexibility with our starting INF), and a designated back-up C (hoping Adley/Basallo can do most of the work without carrying a third).
There’s no room for additional big FA additions in the lineup unless we trade multiple of our young position players. Sorry, that means no Tucker, no Bellinger, no Bader.
As you can see, there’s no room on this roster for Mayo. He has to be traded, hopefully other teams value him. There’s also no room for Mountcastle, who probably has no significant trade value. As much as I’d like to keep him around for his defense (if you’ve forgotten he’s a GG-caliber 1B, Jim Palmer will remind you) and vibes, but his $7.8MM price tag is probably too high for an inflexible, streaky bench bat with hamstring and vestibular injury history. Sadly, Dear Maria count me out, but we’ll always love ya Mounty.
SP:
1. Rogers 2. Bradish 3. Imai/Gallen 4. Lopez/Cabrera/Gore 5. Kremer
Barring more major injuries, this is a top rotation in baseball, and all of the moves to build it are do-able. I’d also consider going with a 6-man rotation with Wells in an attempt to stay healthy. We lack SP depth, but hopefully Povich and Gibson can be that.
BP:
Helsley, 20. Kitteredge, 21. Wells, 22. Cano, 23. Akin, 24. Enns, 25. Garcia, 26. Wolfram Bullpens are a revolving door, but this seems like the group we’re going with for the bulk of the work. Cano needs a bounce back season, or he may be the first man out.
Norfolk Shuttle
Povich, Young, McDermott, Gibson, Nunez
Est. Payroll: $155MM - $177MM, depending on combinations of Free Agent + Trade plans. This leaves plenty of room to work within a budget of $200MM if we need to outbid or make other additions. And hey, everyone spends good money to watch the O’s, put it to good use. I mean, David Rubenstein literally owns the Magna Carta… time to do what it takes to add a World Series trophy to the collection.
Let’s hear your thoughts and see your plans, and try and keep them realistic!