The ups and downs of Final Fantasy Tactics: The Ivalice Chronicles, from the perspective of a guy who played the original a thousand times (XL post)
For those not in the know, Final Fantasy Tactics is a PS1 tactical RPG released in 1997. Telling the intertwining stories of Ramza, youngest son of the powerful and respected noble house Beoulve, and his common-born friend Delita Heiral, it follows the events surrounding a civil war in Ivalice between two dukes contending for control of the throne after the king’s death. It was praised for its depth of systems and complex, mature story exploring the themes of duty, class struggle, and whether or not the ends justify the means, and is widely regarded as a standout of the genre. In 2007 a remaster/update called FFT: The War of the Lions (WotL) was released for the PSP, and in 2025 a second remaster/update, FFT: The Ivalice Chronicles (TIC), was released for all major platforms. I just finished this most recent version for the first time recently, and I have some (many) thoughts to share.
In the interest of full disclosure, I will say upfront that I have massive nostalgia goggles on when it comes to this game. It’s a top-3 all-timer for me and, as the title of this post suggests, I have played both the original and the WotL version many times. Because of this, I’m not really looking to do a review here; there are already hundreds of those out there for you to read if you want, and this would quickly turn into a multi-page gushing fanboy essay if I started talking about the story and characters. I’m more interested in taking a look at the differences between the versions and seeing how the game has evolved over time, what it’s gotten right, and where (even after three attempts) it still goes wrong.
First off, I have to talk about the writing. The story itself is amazing, but the original translation is… Bad. Like, ‘actively makes it hard to understand the plot at times’ level bad. There were beats of the story I still had never fully grasped until playing later versions with updated scripts, and that’s after several playthroughs. WotL completely redid the script, but went with an oddly heavy-handed Shakespearean style of prose which had not been present in the OG. It was far better overall and made the intricacies of the plot much easier to catch, but the language could make you roll your eyes with how flowery it was at times.
TIC, on the other hand, hits it straight out of the park. This third and presumably final script is clean, clear, and has just enough ‘old-timey knights and shit’ flavour to feel like the proper high fantasy political drama it is. I really can’t overstate what a great job they did bringing these characters to life; it’s top tier, best-in-class writing and without a doubt the definitive version of this story. The voice acting is also superb, which is one thing I was a bit nervous about going in.
WotL and the OG are basically identical in terms of HUDs and menus and such, but TIC makes some sweeping changes and with only mixed success. The new combat HUD is excellent, the addition of the turn sequence indicator and the ‘reset move’ button specifically are massive QoL improvements. The icons next to abilities to indicate damage/healing/support were a nice touch as well in a game where abilities often have highly nondescriptive names.
On the other hand, out-of-combat menu navigation felt generally worse to me than it had in previous versions. Menus have been completely overhauled, and the shops, equipment, and jobs menus all felt clunkier and slower to navigate. Like it was taking more button presses to do the same things, which is definitely not ideal for a game where you’re going to spend a lot of time in menus.
Navigating the world map felt much better, as all random battles are now completely optional. You can reject them if you run into them, and you can trigger one yourself when standing on a map space where random encounters occur. While this makes traversal feel much better, especially later in the game when crossing larger sections, it does have the less-than-ideal side effect of completely trivializing the ‘errands’ system. There’s no longer any risk to sending all your best guys on every job, because you know you’ll never be forced to fight while they’re unavailable. This means the entire errands system is now just a button-clicking simulator with no strategy or thought required, but you’ll still want to do them for the xp/jp/money and that’s kind of a bummer.
Unfortunately, while you might think that getting rid of forced random battles would naturally mean reducing grind, according to the fine folks at SquEnix (and this is a direct quote) “fuck you”. TIC is every bit as grindy as the other versions, so get ready to spend a fair bit of time opting in to those random battles if you want to keep your level high enough to progress. The optimal grinding strategy is still to kill every enemy in a battle except one and then group all your guys up and have them hit/cure/buff each other over and over for like 20 straight minutes, which is lame. It’s a real shame that they didn’t take this opportunity to rebalance xp/jp gain or even include an auto level scaling option or something to allow you to opt out of the tediousness, but here we are. You’re also incentivized to grind random battles for the money, as upgrading your gear is even more crucial in this game than most and the in-game economy stays reasonably relevant throughout.
Finally, in the OG and WotL releases, there are (somewhat famously) a couple of points in the game where it is possible to lock yourself out of further progression by entering certain sequences of story battles while at too low a level to beat them. This could actually brick your entire save file if you weren’t using rolling saves and didn’t have a save from before you entered these un-exitable sequences, so unless you knew about this in advance it was entirely possible to find yourself having to start over from scratch after getting 20+ hours deep into the game. Fortunately this has been corrected in TIC, and all multi-battle sequences can be restarted or exited to the world map at any point. In fact, normal one-off battles can now also be restarted directly from the in-combat menu, making it less annoying to reset a fight if it’s going south on you. Very nice touch.
Anyways, I could go on but this post has gotten way too long. If you’ve made it all the way through then thanks for reading, and if you haven’t played FFT yet I seriously suggest correcting that oversight at your earliest opportunity. It is, in my opinion, the best game in the entire Final Fantasy franchise, and I’ve played just about all of them.