Confusion caused by dealership finance person regarding somehow saving money doing a longer loan term with higher interest rate compared to the shorter term
My wife and I went to buy a car recently, and I had some confusion with what the finance person was trying to tell me when we were going through the numbers. So the loan amount was to be for $42000. He laid out two options. A 60 month term with interest rate of 8.49% and minimum payment of 880. The other option was a 72 month term with an interest rate of 8.99% and a minimum monthly payment of 760.
Now this guy was saying that if we took the 72 month option, and paid it at the same amount as the 60 month option (so pay 880 instead of 760) that the extra 120 going towards the principal each month would result in us paying less overall. Now this is where he lost me and I still cannot comprehend how that could be. My thinking was that I would essentially be paying 880 a month, but at an interest rate of 8.99% which would result in more money being paid towards interest. This of course meant that there would be no savings, but the guy was adamant that we would save money this way and he stated that he does all of his personal vehicle loans this same way. I just could not wrap my head around how you would save money by taking the higher interest rate. I asked him if he could show me a breakdown via a graph or chart or something because it would help me understand as I am a visual learner. The best he did was write a few numbers down on a sticky note. Numbers that didn’t even pertain to the loan in question lol.
But overall I am still wondering if he was right. I mean I wanted to give the guy the benefit of the doubt since he does finance stuff for a living, but his attitude towards me when I kept trying to get him to explain it to me better really put me off as he pretty much only tried the one attempt to explain it and said he had never had anyone else that questioned it or that could not understand it. His rationale kept coming down to the fact that the extra payment per month on the longer term would go straight to the principal so you save money, but I just could not see how that is true with the higher interest rate so maybe someone here can break it down for me. I mean I even used some online calculators in front of him with the actual numbers and he pretty much gave up on trying to convince me by just saying “well if that is what the calculators are telling you” lol.
My question is was he right that you would save money by taking a longer term at a higher interest rate, but paying it as if the minimum monthly payment were that of a shorter loan term?
TLDR: do you save money by taking a longer loan term at a higher interest rate, but paying it off as if you were paying the amount for a shorter term? In this case the auto loan would have been for $42000. 60 month term minimum payment of $880 a month with an interest rate of 8.49%. The 72 month term minimum payment would have been $760 a month with an interest rate of 8.99% as well as an extra $120 month towards the principal for a total of $880 paid a month which is to equal the amount of the minimum payment for the 60 month term
[Calculation](https://www.calculator.net/debt-payoff-calculator.html?cnm1=Auto+loan&cbal1=42%2C000&cmpy1=880&cint1=8.49&cnm2=&cbal2=&cmpy2=&cint2=&cnm3=&cbal3=&cmpy3=&cint3=&cnm4=&cbal4=&cmpy4=&cint4=&cnm5=&cbal5=&cmpy5=&cint5=&cnm6=&cbal6=&cmpy6=&cint6=&cnm7=&cbal7=&cmpy7=&cint7=&cnm8=&cbal8=&cmpy8=&cint8=&cnm9=&cbal9=&cmpy9=&cint9=&cnm10=&cbal10=&cmpy10=&cint10=&cnm11=&cbal11=&cmpy11=&cint11=&cnm12=&cbal12=&cmpy12=&cint12=&cnm13=&cbal13=&cmpy13=&cint13=&cnm14=&cbal14=&cmpy14=&cint14=&cnm15=&cbal15=&cmpy15=&cint15=&cnm16=&cbal16=&cmpy16=&cint16=&cnm17=&cbal17=&cmpy17=&cint17=&cnm18=&cbal18=&cmpy18=&cint18=&cnm19=&cbal19=&cmpy19=&cint19=&cnm20=&cbal20=&cmpy20=&cint20=&cextramonthpay=0&cextrayearpay=0&cextraonepay=0&cextraonepayon=1&cfixpay=y&x=Calculate#calresult) I did for the 60 month term.
[Calculation](https://www.calculator.net/debt-payoff-calculator.html?cnm1=Auto+loan&cbal1=42%2C000&cmpy1=760&cint1=8.99&cnm2=&cbal2=&cmpy2=&cint2=&cnm3=&cbal3=&cmpy3=&cint3=&cnm4=&cbal4=&cmpy4=&cint4=&cnm5=&cbal5=&cmpy5=&cint5=&cnm6=&cbal6=&cmpy6=&cint6=&cnm7=&cbal7=&cmpy7=&cint7=&cnm8=&cbal8=&cmpy8=&cint8=&cnm9=&cbal9=&cmpy9=&cint9=&cnm10=&cbal10=&cmpy10=&cint10=&cnm11=&cbal11=&cmpy11=&cint11=&cnm12=&cbal12=&cmpy12=&cint12=&cnm13=&cbal13=&cmpy13=&cint13=&cnm14=&cbal14=&cmpy14=&cint14=&cnm15=&cbal15=&cmpy15=&cint15=&cnm16=&cbal16=&cmpy16=&cint16=&cnm17=&cbal17=&cmpy17=&cint17=&cnm18=&cbal18=&cmpy18=&cint18=&cnm19=&cbal19=&cmpy19=&cint19=&cnm20=&cbal20=&cmpy20=&cint20=&cextramonthpay=120&cextrayearpay=0&cextraonepay=0&cextraonepayon=1&cfixpay=y&x=Calculate#calresult) I did for the 72 month term.
Total interest paid difference $744.15 more in interest for the longer term so no savings which contradicts what the finance person was telling me