Neighborhood property builder says they purchased covenants, but our mortgage and deed both excluded the clause
This is most likely going to end up with us having to get a lawyer, but we're trying to do as much research as we can before we hit that point.
We purchased our home in 2010. It was foreclosed by the builder. The neighborhood was a PVC farm, only 8 houses out of a planned 120 built. We got it for a song.
One of the requirements we had was not wanting to be in a neighborhood with a HOA. Most of the properties our realtor found for us were outside the boundaries of a neighborhood for this reason, but this one seemed to be an exception.
So we bought it, and for six quiet years had nothing but trees around us.
In 2016, we were notified that the HOA was reforming. I contacted our realtor and asked if we should have any concerns, and she recommended going through our mortgage documents to see if there was anything along the lines of "bound by covenant in there." We couldn't find it, nor in the deed of the house, or any of the other paperwork. So our realtor said we were probably fine, but could opt-in if we wanted to. We declined.
Today, just now, a woman from the HOA came around to inform us that we were in arrears to the tune of $600, as was almost everyone else in the neighborhood. The management company that supposedly handles the HOA had done a terrible job sending out invoices, so a lot of the homeowners here are getting a nasty surprise today. I insisted we weren't part of it - had never opted in and it wasn't anywhere in our mortgage paperwork.
She explained that the new construction company had *bought out all the old covenants* on record with the county offices, and our names were included in that. (Which is news to us that the county had that on file to begin with, since it's not anywhere on the mortgage or deed, as I said.)
The threat: That they will put a lien on the house unless we pay the arrears. We've already paid the mortgage off, though, and have no intention of moving, but we'd really not have to deal with untangling that if we can at all avoid it.
Any suggestions for other resources for us to investigate? We can pay $600, but at this point it's not about the money, it's about feeling like we are being scammed.
**UPDATE:** We have contacted the county and confirmed that 1. Title (warranty deed since we're in Georgia) does not list any restrictions, PUDs, easements, etc. 2. Reestablished covenant for the neighborhood includes lots A-G, **but does not include lots in the H section.**
**2nd Update:** Lady who came around actually handed us the paperwork for the house across the street, now that we looked at it more closely. (facepalm) And according to plat, *their* lot actually may be included. So.... we're going to have to find out what house she is in, and explain the situation, and she's going to have to give our neighbors the bad news.