a weird issue I had using a Casio PX-s5000 keyboard as a midi controller
So I just wanted to document my weird journey here. I wanted a new keyboard to move from my beloved kawai mp6. but rather than get the fanciest, I wanted the most compact keyboard that was still "good enough". I stumbled upon a casio px-s5000 at a local piano store. the keys felt nicer than my kawai's, and the action was more fake feeling but VERY controllable for everything but the most rapid fire of pieces. however, using it to control a VST I noticed a weird issue... that despite the computer telling me I had 5 ms of latency, it FELT like WAY more. my first posts to subreddits were met with gaslighting "no one can sense 5 ms" etc. but I did a test... I recorded both audio and midi from the same keyboard, and when I played more notes, there was more latency and almost a weird quantization effect. this made it VERY awkward to feel. casio still has not gotten back to me after showing all the evidence, and I couldn't find a fix for it. they sent it up to HQ in japan for troubleshooting, but it's been two weeks. I am wondering if the USB -> midi on the casio px-s series just can't handle extremely complicated piano music. it worked GREAT for very simple pieces, even more controllable than my kawai. I was able to put a lot of heart into my recordings of things like claire de lune, but playing something heavier like big Liszt pieces just totally felt terrible and awkward. now, it sounded fine without using the MIDI. the onboard piano is just OK, but there's absolutely no noticeable latency there. it was only on the usb -> midi controller, so that is something to consider if you are in the same boat as me.
I used a mac and a PC, two different audio drivers, multiple different DAWs. switching back to the kawai, I realize it was not in my head, and I can run pianoteq with 0 noticeable latency on it. I may sell the casio. it's a shame, it's soooo compact and easy to control, but this is absolutely not ok. I may look into the newer kawai es keyboards instead and spend a little more...