Review: Allure of the Seas
Sharing my review of Allure of the Seas. tl;dr It was overall good once I lowered my expectations.
I went on the Allure of the Seas in August. I had last been on RC in the 2000s, and had done Carnival in the late 2000s and Disney a couple years ago. The Disney cruise really spoiled us. It was significantly more up front, but everything was higher quality and so much more being included meant I didn't feel like I was being up-charged or getting shinkflated.
The highlight was Coco Cay. The island had two large ships docked and rarely felt crowded. We took a tram to a beach and found two chairs for three people within a couple minutes. In comparison, on Disney's island we were searching for a whole. There were beach games to play and probably the best food on the trip. At lunch time most families go back to the ship and it gets even more chill. I took my tired tween back to the room, got him lunch, and he then he hung out there while I stayed at the pool with my wife until dinner.
Entertainment had drama. One night the family karaoke host never showed up. The bartender had to call and ask for someone to help, and a sub took over all the activities and did a great job. Members of the jazz quartet seemed to not get along, which was interesting to watch. The horn orchestra is great, though. Mama Mia was a great show, on par with big regional theater performances. Aqua80Two is awesome, they're talented performers and athletes, and I wish I'd gone twice. That said, those same performers are visibly unenthused when they're in something like the Anchors Aweigh parade which is for kids, and that really is where I expect a performer to put on a happy face.
Cosmetically, there's problems. Our couch had stains. A light in the dining was flickering every night, on for 30 seconds. The floor in Studio B covering the ice has a lot of gaffer's tape covering it. Loudest toilets I've ever heard on a ship, and they have trouble flushing. Maybe they're petty, but the pattern was that these weren't issues of it just being an older ship (although there is a ton of dated art), they co.e across as issues of not keeping up with basic passenger-facing maintenance.
Playmakers would be great, if they made more room for the pool tables by removing the broken arcade machines and unused chance game. Instead the game room winds up being overcrowded. Nonetheless, we were there every night and it was mostly a good group of parents and kids, with the occasional adults who didn't want to give up their table after their game so others could take turns.
The spa only checked my ID the first day. Maybe they recognized me, but on a port day the spa desk was listed as closed for two hours and empty, but the spa open and unlocked, which made me feel dumb for paying. It's also very basic, four heated chairs, two mixed saunas (no gendered saunas), two rainfall showers. Overpriced but functional, and it's worth using the locker rooms (assuming they're free) if you want a larger shower and are comfortable in a shared changing environment.
Johnny Rockets pricing sucks. The only option after breakfast is a prix fixe meal for $18 (per the server) when it used to be actual ala carte. I just wanted to buy onion rings or fries to eat at the boardwalk, no go. That's when I really felt like a walking wallet
Main dining room food was fine. Not amazing, not bad. Shrinkflation applies, no more jumbo shrimp, just some meh not quite medium shrimp. You can still get as much as you want. Kids options were limited and overcomplicated, peppery chicken tenders and four-cheese Mac and cheese.
Windjammer was at times better than the main dining room, which is a both bit of a knock on main and a real compliment to the buffet. It was great to stop after dinner and try the exclusive things and get multiple bite sized desserts. I would pick up a bowl of fruit for the family to snack on at karaoke and game shows.
Park Cafe's ham and cheddar breakfast sandwich is worth making sure you get up a little early for. Grab one and a coffee, then sit at an outside table and relax.
Alcoholic drinks could be poured heavy or light, they were very inconsistent.
I would do RC again and I'm considering Carnival. 20+ years ago Carnival was seen as more of a blue-collar and party cruise, while RC was upper middle-class and fancier. Now both seem to have met in the middle of pursuing family cruisers where the partiers and the fancier cruisers are all on the same board.