That time we let the police remove a player from our group
Maybe NSFW? Definitely not a story I've shared with my kids, so tagging to be safe.
Years ago, when D&D 3.0 came out, I decided to get back into the hobby. The local hobby shop had an LFG board, so I went down and grabbed a few names. A few calls later, I had a group that has been going to this day. However, it almost didn't happen.
Among that first group was a guy whom I shall call Tim. Tim was married, had a kid, job, very good knowledge of 3.0 and understood personal hygiene. Plus, Tim was super eager to DM which was great because I didn't want to run anything at that point. So, invited him and a couple other guys and away we went.
After the very first session it became obvious that Tim wasn't going to be a good fit as DM. He did a few things I don't like (encouraging infighting between the players, adding extra damage to NPC attacks based on how cool he thought his descriptions were), but nothing too alarming.
Further along, the wheels really fell off. Our first adventure was a pretty vanilla hook. Local barmaid had been kidnapped by a roving band of orcs. We track down the orcs to a cave and they are gang-raping the girl. Someone in the group was a paladin, so in keeping with his idea of the code he charged in to put a stop to that. Total party wipe, much to Tim's glee.
In the aftermath, myself and the other players tell Tim, "We're not interested in that kind of campaign. We're thinking more Lord of the Rings like." I tell him that I'll take over as DM and make it clear we're running something more PG. Tim rolls up a Good aligned character and we're off. However, Tim demonstrates he's very much not interested in running the same type of campaign as us. He wants his character to be paid in whores and assaults every female NPC he sees. Total murder-hobo and clearing enjoying it way too much.
I've only known this guy for two weeks and he's already creeping the whole group out. We have a meeting to discuss what to do next and the consensus is he's not a good fit and needs to be removed. So, I get to make the phone call.
However, instead of him I get his wife. Turns out, in the few days since the game session he completely lost his mind. Tim kidnapped her and their daughter, drove them to the next state over, and was threatening to end all three of them. She managed to get away and the police now have him locked up, with the bail set in the six figures. Yikes.
I call one of the other party members to tell him the news, and it turns out Tim has contacted him looking for $15,000 to bail him out. I reiterate, we've known this guy two weeks. Other guy says, "That's a lot of money that I don't have, and I think it would be best if we went our separate ways.
Never heard from him again, but holy crap that was a scary couple of months until he got convicted and sentenced. We got a lot better about vetting people to play with since then.