Intermezzo ending with Peter
I’ve seen quite a lot of posts really disliking Naomi and/or the connotation that they end as a throuple, or that he should only be with Sylvia, that his relationship won’t last with Naomi, but I didn’t read it that way at all.
1. Sylvia tells Peter that she doesn’t want a relationship with him when he breaks up with Naomi for her. She says “the kind of relationship you’re talking about, where I’m the only woman in your life and you give up everything for me, I don’t want that.” When they talk again in the ending, it’s clear that Sylvia wants Peter to love someone else, saying “I think we have to let each other go.” When they agree to form this sort of “arrangement” I think it’s more of Sylvia remaining close friends with Peter while allowing simple romantic gestures, as she holds his arm crossing through town, etc. as they could never be simply “just friends” given their past and the feelings they’ll always have for one another. And Naomi’s OK with this, as she’s in a relationship with Peter, and understands the complexity of Peter/Sylvia history.
2. Peter projected his insecurity about Naomi’s age onto Ivan/Margarets relationship. In the last chapter, he clearly likes Margaret a lot and realizes the conventional strict social norms of age range dating don’t necessarily apply to every scenario. To me, this is him also realizing that a real relationship with Naomi is possible.
3. People seem to think that Peter/Naomi have nothing in common, that he was so cruel to her, etc. whereas I read him having a very deep affection for her. He comments many times on how beautiful she is, and they have great physical chemistry. He loves spending time with her, eating with her, and their usual banter has chemistry (she so unserious, him rolling his eyes but also deeply amused). They say “I love you” to one another and start to build more of that emotional connection by the end of the book. It’s clear that he really does love her, and he’s been trying to talk himself out of loving her or acknowledging his feelings for her for a large portion of the book.
TLDR: I read the ending as Peter being in a relationship with Naomi while also a mutual understanding from all parties that Peter+Sylvia will always have a deep love for one another, now bound more into friendship, yet allowing simple romantic things (like her leaning her head on his shoulder, taking his arm walking through town). It’s vague on where the line is drawn into Peter/Sylvia’s continued romance, but I took it more as allowing Sylvia to still be a major part of his life since she means so much to him as a friend, rather than a full on relationship, which Sylvia says she doesn’t want. And I don’t see how that’s such a problem.