RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/seancarroll • … • u/Compassionate_Cat

Does anyone here feel they strongly understand Sean's understanding of free will?

I'd like to hear it, because I've heard him speak on the subject a few times and have no clue what he's talking about.

Does it include a version of the universe(the multiverse, I assume) where, if you rewound it, we're free to choose otherwise than we did? Or does he substantiate free will in some other way? He rejects *Libertarian* free will, right? But he thinks it's still important/useful to call the things we do "free", or does he actually believe that all things in the universe, including at the level of consciousness, somehow **aren't** running on what is essentially a "physics engine" algorithm(the definition of unfreedom in the meaningful sense).

If you could clarify semantics here, that'd be appreciated too. I'm not interested in "freedom" in the sense that I can move my arm up or down-- to me that isn't freedom. To me, freedom is being able to not be **forced** to move my arm up or down in a moment where the state of the universe says "This is where the agent moves their arm up and down for x duration to demonstrate their freedom", from the decision-level of the agent. Sean would say *that*, specifically, is impossible in a meaningful sense, right?

I use the word meaningful here to discourage quantum nonsense-- QM may be a non-deterministic substrate, but it gives rise to a deterministic one, which is where things like human brains operate-- neurons fire or cause thoughts/behaviors, or not. Specific thoughts lead to specific thoughts, all modulated by the "way one is", none of which is freely chosen by the agent.

If Sean would say that above scenario(not being forced to move one's arm) is our reality, then I'm pretty convinced the position he holds and any disagreement he has with those who say there is no free will, is probably semantic, or based on some utility-type argument(ie, it would be *bad* if we didn't believe in Free Will, irrespective if it's true).

— 0