RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/simracing • … • u/reality_boy

Bass shaker ranking

Here is my proposal for what tactile transducers you should get for sim racing. I am lucky enough to own all of these and have ranked them by performance.

This uses an American style grading system with A, B, C being a 'passing' grade, D being not quite good enough, and F being a fail.

- The Gamer Pro and Advance get an A because they have the lowest frequency response while still being relatively responsive and flat across the range of frequencies we care about. They are also 2-4x more expensive than the budget models, but still not that expensive. - The BST300EX and Gamer Plus/2 get a B because they are more than good enough, if not the very best options. Personally, if your going for a Plus, then spend the extra money on the pro, it is less than 20% more and a better value. - The Dayton BST-1 and Aura ATS-2B-4 fall to C level. They are good enough for the price, but if you can swing for the BST-300EX for $30 more then go for it. I consider these good based only on there price, they feel quite a bit more muted then the Advance/Gamer Pro. - The Dayton BST-2 gets a D because it really does not perform nearly as well as the BST-1, but only saves you a few dollars. Spend the money getting a better shaker. The ButtKicker 2 (LFE, Concert) gets a D because it is sluggish and does not react well across the whole range of frequencies we want to drive it with. It could be great as a secondary shaker that only comes on when the power demands are high, but as a primary shaker it falls flat. The Advance is a much better choice. - In the F category we have the tiny Dayton TT25-8, it just lacks the power needed to get the job done. Also the Clark TST209 and TST239 are here because they have very little response below 100 Hz and that knocks them out of the sub audible category. They could be paired with a full sized LFE to get a broader frequency response, but on there own they don't work nearly well enough, certainly not well enough to justify there price. That makes some sense, they are more contact speakers than low frequency shakers. - I did not add them to the list but all the super budget shakers you can get from AliExpress and Ebay are in the D and F category as well. Getting a shaker for $20 sounds great, but it really is not enough of a savings to justify the loss in performance. Go with the BST-1 if money is tight, you will get a lot more out of it. - On the right side I listed off the transducers I have not yet tried. Most of these are quite expensive, so I don't have high hopes that they will be a better value then the ButtKicker Advance/Gamer Pro. Still it is possible the Earthquake Q10B/MQB-1 or IBEAM could be as good or better. And the Reckhorn is one of many similar transducers that are not easily available in America, but that are common in other parts of the world. They probably all fall somewhere in the B-D category, but I have no reasonable way to test them out to be sure.

— 0