Why the first meeting in A New Hope doesn’t rule out Vader and Obi-Wan meeting in between Ep3-4. And how a conversation in Return of the Jedi sets up the “rematch of the century”
Disclaimer * This is not word for word or my theory originally.
The Return of the Jedi conversation on Endor. After Luke’s surrender. When Luke says “there is still good in you” and Vader replies “Obi Wan once felt the same as you” ....there is absolutely no reason for Obi Wan to, at one point, feel Anakin could be redeemed and then at another feel differently without a meeting between the two because that’s the only way Vader would know his opinion changed!!!
BOOM!
Not my theory.