RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/starwarsspeculation • … • u/indoninjah

The implications of Jedi celibacy

I was reading [this post](https://reddit.com/r/starwarsspeculation/comments/wyzjov/why_is_it_so_rare_for_mandalorians_to_be_force/) and thinking more about the Jedi's monopoly of strong Force sensitives in the Galaxy, and how that ties into their views of rejecting attachment/relationships/having children.

**TL;DR: What if a Sith meddled in the Jedi dogma at some point, and pushed them towards celibacy, in hopes of making the Jedi die out?**

I think there's a few relevant pieces of info to consider here:

* We know that the Jedi typically embrace celibacy and reject relationships. There's some exceptions (e.g. Ki Adi Mundi) but as a whole, the Jedi are forbidden from having families. Luke has obviously rejected this with his new Jedi Order, given that he cares deeply about his family (and doesn't mind that Leia, who received Jedi training, has a son).

* We know that Force sensitivity is passed down as a hereditary trait (the Skywalkers and, to a lesser extent, the Palpatines).

* We know that the Sith have meddled with the Jedi in the past (specifically in the PT, where Palpatine maneuvers the Jedi into a position that compromises their believes).

The Jedi welcome children with strong Force sensitivity into their order, but never allow them to have a family or children of their own. In effect, any child who is strong enough with the Force to become a Jedi, is basically a *mutant*, otherwise their parent(s) would have been Jedi. Out of the trillions in the Galaxy, there's only 10,000 or so Jedi. This is a relatively tiny number, and we see how quickly the Jedi get overburdened when presented with a Galactic scale conflict like the Clone Wars.

I wonder if this was an intentional move by the Sith at some point. If Jedi were allowed to have children, they could have stronger children who in turn would become strong Jedi. But if you forbade them from having children, you basically put a massive choke point on the source of Jedi in the Galaxy. If strong Force sensitivities were allowed to freely have children, it's likely that Force sensitivity would eventually become the dominant trait throughout the Galaxy (or at least pockets of the Galaxy), just by Darwinism.

This would be disastrous to the Sith, if Jedi were allowed to amass their numbers up to *the millions*. The Sith may be vastly outnumbered 10,000 to 2, but obviously killing off that many Jedi was within the realm of possibility. With more massive numbers, usurping the Jedi would be entirely impossible.

So I think it would be interesting to see a plot point at some point during pretty ancient times - post-Jedi vs. Sith wars but pre-Republic. The Jedi doctrine mostly speaks to being compassionate towards all beings, but seems contradictory in that you must remove all attachments to family and loved ones. What if this were the result of Sith influence nudging them more towards celibacy and monk-hood? We know that Palpatine has managed to cloud Yoda's judgement in the PT, maybe a former Sith could influence the direction of a former Jedi Grand Master.

— 0