How did you make siege combat more interesting?
Hey y'all - I'm going to run the Triboar attack on Monday, and was wondering what other people have done to make siege combat interesting.
I've upped the scale of this encounter up based on the description I gave my group at the end of the last session.
The general idea is that the piece under Triboar is way more than just the c-shaped adamantine band described in the book. It's a specifically very important part, and so the siege is scaled up. In planning on there being 7+ Giants based on narrative, but I think the party will directly encounter about 4.
I'm going to have 2 main encounters (as per the DMguide for Triboar) with variations depending on whether that piece is tackled first, second or not at all). The only way to play the first phase of both encounters would be to split the party.
In the first phase the giant digging encounter will be geared around stopping the dig. 2 Giants are digging through the ground, and a fire giant with some magical abilities is watching over them. There will also be some orogs and magmins. In the second phase, it'll be run as a chase trying to stop the Giants before the reach the giant crater they busted out of to start the attack.
The town side encounter will be combat against axbeaks and magmins (maybe one giant) in the first phase. Then second phase will be skill challenges to save beloved NPCs.
I'm still not sure if this will convey the scale of the attack I'm picturing in my head. The one classic trope missing from this, is a tower defense as the Giants and orcs approach the town. What do you think of an encounter where they all play as NPC archers for 1 round, trying to stand against the Giants throwing rocks on the wall? I'm hesitant to put the PCs on the wall because I feel like that would derail the whole siege.
Has anyone designed set pieces that did a good job conveying the scale of the battle and massive destruction that these forces can cause?