RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/strictlycomedancing • … • u/paolog

"Based on the dance-off alone..."

When judging the dance-off, do the judges go by how well the celebrities danced on their second attempt or their improvement since the main show? I always thought it was the first, and the requirement "Based on (etc)" suggests that's what is supposed to be, but the judges often seem to rate the couples on how much better they danced. In my opinion, Melanie danced better than Shaun in Sunday's show, and yet it was Shaun who was voted through (although not unanimously).

— 0