RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/stunfisk • … • u/Sunset_42

Paradox vs Originals Comparison - Amoongus

Hi I'm going to be doing an analysis of all the paradox pokemon to see which ones are better than their originals and which ones aren't. I've played pokemon for a while but I'm still a bit of an amateur in doubles so if there are any corrections people have feel free to put it in the comments. Today is the sus pokemon himself Amoongus which has a past counterpart in Brute Bonnet.

Roles: In singles Amoongus is mainly a decently bulky spore support pokemon with some offensive special damage, whereas Brute Bonnet is a tanky physical attacker that happens to run spore. In doubles Amoongus is a strong redirection sleeper with other supporting moves whereas BB is a mixed redirection sleeper support with physical offensive capabilities.

Typing: Defensively Amoongus has a much better typing. Both are bulky slow pokemon which means that they want to have really good defensive typing, and while BB has more resistances and an immunity, it also has way more weaknesses especially to common types including a 4x weakness to bug, which is pretty bad as it can hit for a lot by bad match-ups u-turning out before it can move. Amoongus also resists more common attacking types in fighting and fairy. It's poison type also prevents it from getting chipped down by poison though this is less common in SV due to less pokemon knowing toxic now. Offensively BB does have the better typing as carrying both STABS it can hit most things for at least neutral, though Amoongus's poison is good for fairy. Ultimately this benefits BB well as it's a more offensive pokemon but isn't actually very detrimental to Amoongus who is more support oriented and it straight up doesn't matter for doubles Amoongus which barely ever is attacking. Ultimately in terms of typing overall helping them in their roles Amoongus has the far greater edge. Overall 1) Amoongus.

Stats: Overall BST: BB has a way better overall BST by almost 100 points but of course, as always it's not about how big your BST is but how you use it (in this case how you allocate it but whatever). Physical & Special Bulk: BB has much better bulk for both physical and special statwise than Amoongus, something it greatly needs with it's worse offensive typing. Though Amoongus' slightly higher HP stat helps it out with the correct ability. 1) BB. Speed: In terms of speed Brute Bonnet is technically faster by 25 points, but this actually to it's detriment. 55 speed isn't super useful as you're not going to be out speeding most things, and is higher than you'd like for trick room settings where Amoongus's slower speed makes it much better allowing it to get off spores before most things. So in this case Amoongus wins out. 1) Amoongus. Attacks: While technically Amoongus has the same stat for both it's phys and special it really only ever runs special, while BB runs physical attacks and both are better than the other with their respectively used attack stat. That said BB has a way higher primary attack stat making it the winner of this category, not that doubles Amoongus minds much. 1) BB.

Ability: Now don't get me wrong Protosynthesis is a great ability, however it's pretty bad on Brute Bonnet. If you want to use it you either need to give up your item slot for a booster energy, or you need to have sun up, however if sun is up then BB needs to terra or get oneshot by any fire move which is not great. The only stat it can really boost is it's high attack stat which it can't take that great advantage of with it's slow speed without trick room and even then it's not great. The only other options it can have to boost are it's defensive stats but in order to do this it requires you to barely invest in attack which is it's best stat. In other words the benefits of this ability aren't usually worth the investment needed to get them (Terra/item slot/small atk evs). On the other hand Amoongus has a fantastic ability in regenerator. Giving it great survivability in singles to switch in and out and get more uses of spore off, and in doubles increases it's effectiveness as a redirector allowing it both to get more uses of spore off and redirect more damage. So hands down no contest 1) Amoongus.

Movepools: In terms of movepools overall they have pretty close to the same moves however this movepool benefits Amoongus far more. BB lacks a really strong physical grass type move, not that there are many to begin with, it's best options being bullet seed which is inconsistent without loaded dice or trailblaze to try and get fast enough to outspeed things. In terms of physical dark it has some ok options, though tends to just run sucker punch to try and makeup for it's bad speed. In general it doesn't have any non-normal physical moves that break 80 base power except for CC (which sucks on it as it isn't fast meaning it has to switch out or get easily revenge killed or regular killed if it doesn't kill). This can kind of be made up for with terra blast but again this forces you to waste your terra on it. In comparison Amoongus gets slightly stronger or better supportive special moves, like sludge bomb and giga drain for damage and clear smog to remove buffs or pollen puff to heal your partner in doubles. It also gets access to foul play allowing it to do good damage physical on strong physical enemies. In other words it's 1) Amooungus.

Overall: Despite having a better BST Brute Bonnet still loses out to the Sussiest mushroom and ultimately it can be boiled down to the three reasons. First Its new stats just don't play that well with the movepool it got and would have been better off as a special attacker rather than physical. Second while it's new typing does help it become stronger offensively it also makes it way worse defensively which is not good for a slow pokemon. And third is that Protosynthesis just doesn't help it out as much as Regenerator does, especially as its typing leaves it weak to fire, as it probably would have been better off with something that resists fire as a secondary like rock or water. Both which would have still fit it themeattically with its whole mushroom moss thing. The fact is that in trying to become more of a mixed role tank attacker+ support pokemon it becomes more mediocre when compared to Amoongus that just does one thing really well, and that's to support the team with a bit of damage tacked on. Current timeline wins.

Paradox -1 Current timeline -1 Next will probably be Delibird (though we all know who wins there, it's more a breakdown of the specifics of why.)

— 0