RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/stunfisk • … • u/reaperfan

Hypothetical balance question - Would Hyper Beam (and the other moves similar to it) be OP if they "canonized" the bug it had in Gen 1?

Full disclosure, I'm more of an "observer" of competitive play rather than someone who actually participates in it myself. Basically, I follow things pretty well but don't have much practical experience, so please take this question with that frame of reference in mind. I've also got two different ideas about how this could be implemented, so please read through for both of those if you would.

That said, in case anyone for some reason doesn't know, the bug in question was that in Gen 1 if Hyper Beam actually managed to score the KO on something then it'd skip the recharge turn and you'd be allowed to attack again immediately. If this effect was reintroduced to the move (and similar moves like Giga Impact or Blast Burn), would it actually be all that OP?

I guess what I want to say is that this comes from a place of seeing the moves rarely being used as they are but also realizing that if this ever did come back I feel with all the new options we've got now it'd make the strategy predictable enough to be played around. The moves would be powerful, sure, but they'd come with the inherent risk of - say - getting swapped into a resisted hit which doesn't actually KO or just simply being Protected which causes the user to become very vulnerable. Obviously that same risk exists now, but with the "bug" brought back I feel there'd also enough of a reward to make that risk actually worth taking (as opposed to now where it's basically never worth it).

As for the two options I talked about earlier, since I wasn't sure if this would be too powerful on its own I also thought of the idea that rather than simply bringing this effect back as a baseline effect of the attacks, if that would maybe be too powerful then to maybe instead introduce it as the effect of an ability instead. I feel like making it an ability would make for a kind of "middle ground" solution because it would:

1. Make it even more predictable due to everyone knowing the distributions of who can actually have access to the strat, and 2. Prevent it from compounding with other potential damage-boosting abilities (aka something like Porygon-Z would have to give up Adaptability to be able to take advantage)

---------------

I dunno, it's been a curiosity that's been on my mind a figured I'd finally float the question to people who probably know better than I do. What do you all think of this hypothetical change? Would it actually make the moves usable or would it go too far and make them too strong? I'd be really interested to hear anyone else's thoughts!

— 0