RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/stunfisk • … • u/XionGaTaosenai

What if Volcanion was in RBY?

(This is part of a weekly series. See [this post](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1hhy8d2/ksyons_rby_port_ideas_masterpost/) for information on my general methodology, links to previous entries, and a list of pokemon I plan to cover in the future. Since this series is close to wrapping up and I've already chosen the remaining pokemon I want to cover, I am no longer taking requests for reviews.)

**Volcanion**

*Fire/Water type*

* HP: 80 * Attack: 110 * Defense: 120 * Speed: 70 * Special: 130

Moves:

* Take Down * Mist * Haze * Stomp * Body Slam * Hydro Pump * Explosion * Steam Eruption (*signature move*) * Toxic * Take Down * Double-Edge * Bubblebeam * Water Gun * Hyper Beam * Rage * Earthquake * Fissure * Mimic * Double Team * Reflect * Bide * Selfdestruct * Fire Blast * Rest * Rock Slide * Substitute * Cut * Strength

Someone really wanted to see this review, because they requested it *twice*, albeit never in the place where I actually wanted people to put their requests. I suspect that the reason why is its signature move, Steam Eruption - a move that can be used while frozen and thaws out the user. Freeze is infamous in Gen I for having practically no way to cure it in Gen I PvP - unless your opponent is running a pokemon with Fire Blast and lets you swap your frozen pokemon into it, a frozen pokemon is permanently out of the game. However, Volcanion would, in theory, be the one exception to this rule, which combined with its ice resistance (sadly only a x2 resistance instead of x4, since ice is neutral against fire in Gen I) would let it switch into enemy ice attacks with a degree of safety no other pokemon enjoys, and shut down any opponent's attempt at freeze fishing.

Unfortunately, things don't quite work out that way. In Gen I, being frozen doesn't just remove your ability to attack - it removes your ability to even *select an attack*. Clicking "fight" while frozen simply causes you to automatically pass the turn without even getting to see the list of your moves. For Steam Eruption to be able to thaw you, you would first have to be able to *select* the move, and while you could argue that RBY would have been coded to allow such a thing if it had a move like Steam Eruption in it, that's still a bigger change to RBY's coding than I'm comfortable allowing, so I'm going to say that in this hypothetical timeline, Steam Eruption *existed*, but didn't gain the ability to thaw out its own user until Gen II. Even if Volcanion was able to thaw itself, freezing is a much smaller part of RBY's meta today than it might have been in the past (and was probably *never* as big a part of the meta as people unfamiliar with Gen I seem to think it is), so getting into a situation where the opponent is trying to freeze fish and swapping in your Volcanion to block it is just not going to happen often enough to justify a teamslot for Volcanion on that alone.

On the other hand, Steam Eruption won't be able to accidentally thaw *opposing* pokemon either, despite being able to inflict a burn - we actually have real precedent for that in Scald being unable to thaw pokemon until Gen VI. So Volcanion would be unique among RBY pokemon in being able to threaten burns on opposing pokemon like Tauros and Snorlax without the risk of thawing an enemy's frozen pokemon if they switch one in. Steam Eruption would also be able to burn fire types, but *wouldn't* be able to burn water types, which is actually kind of a blessing in disguise, since that means it can't accidentally burn an enemy Starmie and render it unable to be paralyzed. Chansey and Alakazam, however, would still be able to take advantage, and an odd shortcoming of Volcanion is that *it doesn't learn Surf*, so if you want to run a water type STAB move, you have to deal with either Hydro Pump's lower accuracy or the double-edged sword of Steam Eruption's burn chance.

With freeze-related gimmicks being unable to carry Volcanion, what it actually has going for it is a huge stat block and the ability to Explode. Fire/Water is a unique type combination, but the fire typing doesn't really add any significant advantages over just being a pure water type, while saddling Volcanion with a nasty weakness to Earthquake, which prevents it from standing up to the likes of Tauros or Snorlax as well as its statline suggests it should. Volcanion has a decent spread of coverage by RBY standards, with ground, rock, fire, and water in its toolbelt, but its offensive options leave it with no way to seriously threaten enemy water types, and it has no real support movepool to speak of - no boosting moves, no recovery other than Rest, and a complete reliance on Body Slam if it wants to spread paralysis.

Explosion, however, is very nice. One of the things that tends to hold back pokemon that can only click basic damaging attacks is that they can give a pretty easy entry to enemy Starmies, but Volcanion's explosion does 90% minimum to Starmie, so even a resisted Steam Eruption will put a Starmie that switches in into guaranteed Explosion KO range. After that, clicking any move that isn't Recover is a huge risk for the Starmie, but if the Starmie *does* use Recover and Volcanion uses any move other than Explosion, then Starmie gets chipped back down to 80% again and you're right back where you started (and possibly ate a Body Slam para in the process, in which case GG). And even if you do Recover and the Volcanion explodes, Volcanion's Explosion has an almost 40% chance to OHKO Starmie from full HP anyway! It's just not a matchup that Starmie wants to fight at all, and anything that scares Starmie is huge. Chansey and Alakazam also both get OHKOd by Volcanion's Explosion, even at 100%, so there's really nothing that can comfortably switch into a Volcanion's burning moves. Volcanion still suffers from a significant lack of versatility or general utility, and an exploder that doesn't give you any other value before exploding is only as good as the pokemon it trades with, but it would definitely have potential, and would be one of the best pokemon in the game for trying to actively utilize burn as a strategy, given its ability to intimidate the pokemon that are generally the biggest roadblocks to burn-based tactics in RBY OU.

In UU, Volcanion's stat total would simply be too big to ignore. Volcanion's damage and bulk are both very high for the tier, and it has the coverage to hit both ground and electric pokemon, so finding a solid counter to Volcanion is hard. Burn is also a lot more menacing in UU, since Kadabra is the only pokemon that can really exploit it and it has much more significant flaws in general than Alakazam, Starmie, or Chansey have in OU. Evaluated as a fire type, Volcanion has more physical bulk than Ninetales or Moltres, has an even stronger Fire Blast than Moltres does, actually resists ice type attacks, demolishes any other fire type 1v1 thanks to having water STAB, and always has that Explosion in its back pocket if it needs it, but would have to deal with being the slowest of the three by a fair margin, though it still outspeeds Hypno and Lapras. It trades its water weakness for an electric weakness, but still has as rough of a time *dealing* damage to enemy water types as any other fire pokemon, and with very little utility to offer outside of its damage, water types would probably still be Volcanion's principal checks, either walling it or forcing it to go boom.

— 0