RBY What-If's: The honorable mentions
(This is part of a weekly series. See [this post](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1hhy8d2/ksyons_rby_port_ideas_masterpost/) for information on my general methodology, links to previous entries, and a list of pokemon I plan to cover in the future. Since this series is close to wrapping up and I've already chosen the remaining pokemon I want to cover, I am no longer taking requests for reviews.)
After almost 21 months of posting every single Thursday, I've decided that it is time to bring this series to a close - or at least take a very long break while waiting for a new generation of Pokemon to come out and give me a fresh supply of ideas. My final installment will be going up next Thursday, but this week, I wanted to do something a little bit different. There are several pokemon that I thought deserved a few words in their honor, but for one reason or another I didn't want to do a full write-up on. I'm not going to be coming up with a stat spread or movepool for any of these pokemon, but I'll explain why I specifically didn't want to give any of these pokemon a proper review, and then give some quick impressions of what might be the most interesting things about them if I did do one.
**Espeon/Leafeon/Glaceon**
The eeveelutions are some of the most popular pokemon in the entire franchise, and the non-Gen I menbers of the group were naturally some of the first pokemon that crossed my mind when thinking of pokemon to review. Umbreon and Sylveon are obviously out of the question, being mono-dark and mono-fairy respectively, but what was wrong with the other three?
Well, ultimately, the problem comes down to parity. The eeveelutions are very tightly designed to exist in perfect parallel to one another - not only are their base stats always the same six numbers, just arranged differently, their movepools are arranged such that every eeveelution learns moves at the same levels, which by necessity means that they also learn the same number of moves via level up. In Generation I, this number is **10**, so any new eeveelution needs to learn at least 10 moves via level up that either existed in Gen I or could be included as a signature move (assuming we're okay with giving a new eeveelution a signature move when none of the original three have one). This is a bar that no eeveelution outside of the ones already in Gen I can meet - too much of their respective level-up movepools are filled with moves that did not exist in Gen I. I have reviewed pokemon that would have had conspicuously sparse level-up movepools if limited to only Gen I moves before, such as [Togekiss](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1ionm20/what_if_togekiss_was_in_rby/) and [Gastrodon](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1vazmo4/what_if_gastrodon_was_in_rby/), but with the eeveelutions, the fact that they would have such a glaring mismatch with their actual Gen I counterparts is an awkwardness that I couldn't ignore and didn't want to address.
When I make these reviews, I'm not just trying to port a modern pokemon to RBY, I'm *imagining an alternate timeline where that pokemon was included in the original 1996 game from the beginning*, and one of the rules I follow is that in this alternate timeline, the pokemon as it exists *today* is unchanged. This is why I can't simply add moves to a pokemon's movepool to fill gaps like this, because if I did that, I would have to come up with an explanation for why the pokemon *can't* learn that move today - pokemon *losing* moves that they were able to learn via level-up in a previous generation is a fairly rare occurrence (at least before Gen VIII where a lot of older moves were outright removed from the game).
So if I didn't care about any of that and reviewed the eeveelutions anyway, what would they be like? If we assume that Espeon gets to carry Morning Sun as a signature move, it becomes another fast psychic type with a recovery move, but it lacks Thunder Wave or any legitimate coverage move (it wouldn't even have Seismic Toss). It has no way to seriously compete with Alakazam, much less Starmie, so it has no real business being in OU and goes to UU to compete with Kadabra, who still has a way better movepool than Espeon, but Espeon's stats make it a more fair competition. Leafeon would be a swords dancer with Razor Leaf coverage while lacking the drawbacks that come with Venusaur or Victreebel's poison typing, but it doesn't learn any status moves, which is normally the calling card of grass-type swords dancers, Leafeon's low special makes Razor Leaf less valuable than it otherwise would be, and it doesn't have any coverage outside of that. Overall, it seems pretty mediocre. Finally, Glaceon gets to shoot of Blizzards that are even stronger than Articuno's (if only slightly) and doesn't have the weaknesses of Articuno's flying typing, but it struggles to compete with Articuno in bulk and speed and lacks Agility without having anything in its movepool to make up for it, so I think it ultimately plays second fiddle to Articuno.
**Starters**
I knew from the beginning of this series that I did not want to cover a single starter in isolation - if I was going to *any* starter, I wanted to do a trio of a grass, fire, and water type. The didn't necessarily have to all be from the same generation, but they *did* need to share the same base stat total after adjusting for only having a single special stat, or at least be close (ideally, all three would have a BST of 425 like the actual Gen I starters did in RBY, but that part proved to be impossible). There were a few candidate trios, but all of them were pretty scattershot by nature, being groupings of starters that just happened to share a BST rather than anything deliberately chosen. Ultimately, I just got to a point where, given the limit of 100 pokemon I had set, I didn't feel like I had room for three reviews to cover some random selection of starters that I may not even be that passionate about individually.
However, I wanted to give a particular shout-out to **Meganium**. Competitively, Meganium seems okay but not spectacular - assuming we keep its stat total the same as Venusaur's, it has higher defense than Venusaur, no poison typing, and access to Earthquake, but lower special and no Sleep Powder. However, Chikorita would be an incredible pokemon from a *speedrunning* perspective, assuming you could pick it as a starter - not only would it have all the advantages of being a grass type starter in a game where the first three gyms are rock/water/electric, it learns Razor Leaf at *level 8*, which with RBY's crit mechanics is an absurd move to have that early in the game. Chikorita often gets a bad rap as being one of the weakest starters in the series, but I've heard the argument that if Chikorita was the grass type starter in *any other generation*, it would actually be one of the *strongest* starters in the series (again, in a singleplayer/speedrunning perspective, not competitively) - it's just that Gen II in particular is uniquely hostile to a grass-type starter of any caliber.
**Uxie/Azelf**
This issue of "parity" is going to be a recurring theme in these honorable mentions, because it's far an away the most common reason why I reject a potential review. There are simply lots of pokemon that are designed to exist in parallel to other counterparts - regional forms, other members of a pair or trio, and so on - and the symmetry that they have in the generation where they made their debut is impossible to maintain with only one special stat and the limits to RBY movepools, at least not without making changes to the pokemon that I wouldn't be comfortable making. In particular, there are several sets of legendary pokemon where one or two of the pokemon seem interesting to cover, but the third throws a spanner into the works, being impossible to design symmetrically with the others, but reviewing only part of the trio/quartet would feel incomplete.
Among the Lake Guardians, Mesprit is the odd one out - its balanced stats means that it would wind up having an either way lower or way higher stat total than its contemporaries, and of the moves that differ between the three in their level-up movepools, Mesprit learns no Gen I moves, while Uxie has Amnesia and Azelf has Explosion. These two moves in particular are actually what would make me interested in covering Uxie and Azelf. Uxie is one of very few psychic types that can learn Amnesia via level-up, despite Amnesia being a psychic type move, and Uxie would be a psychic type Amnesia user that's faster than Slowbro, but is not *Mewtwo* or [*Swoobat*](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1lkxg9z/what_if_swoobat_was_in_rby/) \- in other words, it's the Goldilocks of fast psychic type Amnesia users, and has a decent shot at actually being usable in OU. Meanwhile, Azelf would have the highest attack of any Explosion user in RBY, with a boom that only barely comes short of Snorlax's STAB Selfdestruct, while also having the second highest speed of any Explosion user in RBY, having the same speed as Starmie. It would pretty much be the most dangerous exploder in the game, while also having STAB Psychic and Thunderbolt coverage off of a pretty high special alongside Thunder Wave, so it's well equipped to cause a lot of damage even without going boom.
**Terrakion**
I got several requests for Terrakion in particular, probably because it's a fighting type with a huge stat total and a secondary typing that lets it resist normal moves. Unfortunately, that ground weakness isn't doing it any favors, but its stats are probably high enough to carry it into some amount of OU relevance anyway. Maybe not an OU proper pokemon, but I could see it having a niche.
The issue of covering Terrakion is, of course, Virizion and Cobalion, and probably Keledo as well. Cobalion would have to be a mono-fighting type since the steel type does exist, and while Virizion doesn't have anything obviously wrong with it, the bigger issue is that the other swords of justice just wouldn't be that interesting to cover. They're all just fighting types with huge stat totals that I would feel obligated to cover just because I covered Terrakion, and while there's room to ponder how big of a stat total a fighting type would need to be relevant in RBY OU, it's not really a conversation that needs to be had *four times*.
**Galarian Articuno/Zapdos**
The obvious problem here is Galarian Moltres, due to there being no dark type in Gen I, which is a problem not just for G!Moltres for for its signature move Firey Wrath as well. However, the two members of this trio that could have been adapted with little issue are both very interesting to consider, even if I wouldn't want to actually cover them without out being able to do the third. Galarian Articuno is, as far as I'm aware, the only pokemon that learns both a sleep-inducing *and* Recover in its level-up movepool, wioth most psychic types in RBY being defined by their ability to learn one or the other. It's movepool outside of that is pretty barren, but just having Hypnosis + Recover opens doors that aren't accessible to any other psychic type. Freezing glare is cute for its ability to freeze ice types, but the special drops from regular Psychic are probably more reliable. Galarian Zapdos's Thunderous Kick, however, has a lot of potential. The porblem with most fighting type attacks is that your opponent is bound to have a psychic type or two that can switch in on them for basically free, but Thunderous Kick's guaranteed defense drop throws a wrench into that plan. The small amount of chip damage from Thunderous Kick itself, combined with the defense drop, put both Exeggutor and Alakazam in guaranteed OHKO range of G!Zapdos's Drill Peck and Hyper Beam respectively, and even Starmie is put in a bad position.
**Mr. Rime**
The last of the pokemon I rejected for "parity" reasons, this time being a mismatch between Galarian Mr. Mime and its Kantonian counterpart. In addition to an issue with stats, Mr.Mime's movepool actually changed dramatically in the transition to Gen VIII, and literally half of the moves it learns by level-up in Gen I *don't even exist* in the generation where G!Mr. Mime was introduced, so figuring out what G!Mr. Mime's movepool would have been like had it been in Gen I is way more difficult than it has any right to be.
Mr. Rime is kind of like a better version of Hypno. It's a dual status pokemon that's fairly slow but still faster than Exeggutor, and kind of a "middle of the road" psychic type that combines many of the good qualities of other strong psychic types, but lacks the most standout qualities of any of them. It has BlizzBolt coverage like Starmie does, and Blizzard is a much better STAB move to have than Surf in addition to the benefits of not being weak to electric or grass moves, but it doesn't have Starmie's speed or Recover. It can spread both sleep and paralysis, is faster than Exeggutor, and doesn't have to worry about ice moves, but it can't switch into Earthquakes as easily as Exeggutor can and it can't Explode. but overall, Mr. Rime seems pretty solid, and even if it's not as flashy as some of its competition, I think it would easily find a place in OU.
**Porygon-Z/Ursaluna/Mamoswine/Dusknoir**
The common thread between these four pokemon is that they're the evolved from of a pokemon I did review ([Porygon2](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1hmrlnz/what_if_porygon2_was_in_rby/)/[Ursaring](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1hrzcnn/what_if_ursaring_was_in_rby/)/[Piloswine](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1i89ieh/what_if_piloswine_was_in_rby/)/[Dusclops](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1jqqyi1/what_if_dusclops_was_in_rby/)), meaning that for each of them I made an intentional choice to review the weaker version over the stronger one. For most of them, I took some time to make a note about them in the review of their pre-evolved form, so I'm not going to spend much breath repeating myself here - Porygon-Z trait of higher offenses/lower defenses than Porygon2 is hard to reconcile with Gen I's single special stat, Dusclops was already dramitically changed by having its 130 special defense be its special attack as well and I wanted to review it like it was a kind of mirror to Chansey, and I felt that Piloswine was already good enough as-is to hack it in OU, so Mamoswine's extra power wasn't necessary. But I didn't say anything about Ursaluna, at least not in the main body of the review - I've had *plenty* of chances to make my thoughts on Ursaluna known, both in the comments of that post and in later posts.
Ursaluna would be an absolute *monster*. There are several pokemon that I've covered or discussed that I would not be surprised to see kicked to Ubers if they were actually in the game - Lickilicky, Mamoswine, *Ursaring itself* \- but Ursaluna is the only non-legendary pokemon that I would say *absolutely* would be banned to Ubers. You're taking everything that was outrageous about Ursaring - already a pokemon that I think is borderline Ubers material - and adding a substantial bulk increase and a STAB Earthquake on top of that. The only downsides are a few extra weaknesses - most notably to Blizzard - and the fact that Exeggutor outspeeds you instead of tying with you, but I don't think those are enough to offset the absurd destructive power this pokemon would have.
**Bellossom**
I realized like a year after the fact that I forgot to cover this thing when I was doing [a batch of other Gen II evolutions](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1ija3uf/what_if_slowking_politoed_crobat_and_kingdra_were/), and I've kind of been kicking myself for it since because I kind of like Bellossom, but people would *riot* if I dedicated an entire review just to this thing. Bellossom is Vileplume without a poison typing. That's the only difference between the two. They had no differences in movepool in Gen II, and the only difference other than their typing was that their special attack and special defense stats were swapped - but with only one special stat in Gen I, the only way to keep their BSTs the same would be to give them both 100 special. Losing the poison typing is pretty much purely a buff for Bellossom, and that buff might allow Bellossom to rise from ZU to PU! Wow! What a glow-up!
**Gholdengo**
I got a request for Gholdengo pretty early on, and at the time, I gave a "wait and see" response, since I already had a lot of ghost types on my plate and didn't want my reviews to become too ghost-heavy. But, I understand why pretty much every ghost type you can think of would be an interesting subject to review - the ghost type in Gen I represents such a massive amount of wasted potential, being a type that has no practical weaknesses but is held back by there only being one line of them in the whole game, and every member of that line also having the horrible poison typing to further restrict them. But at the end of the day, I feel like I covered more than enough ghost types. Gholdengo, however, might have been one of the strongest. It would have been a mono-ghost type, since the steel type doesn't exist, and I wouldn't give it Make it Rain for the same reason I didn't give [Metagross](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1k1hsah/what_if_metagross_was_in_rby/) Meteor Mash (steel-type move), but it would be a mono-ghost type with very decent bulk, no real weaknesses, and access to Recover. Even if I limited it to only having 91 special, this thing would be a chore to kill, all while being able to chuck around Thunder Waves as it pleases. [Dusclops](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1jqqyi1/what_if_dusclops_was_in_rby/) and [Avalugg](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1pvfku2/what_if_avalugg_was_in_rby/) were already pokemon that could potentially transform the meta due to being able to comfortably switch into Tauros, with Dusclops being a bulky ghost type and Avalugg having Recover, and Gholdengo has the good qualities of both them while *also* having TWave. Gholdengo would be a *menace* \- not as overwhelmingly strong as Ursaluna, by any means, but possibly even more annoying to deal with.
**Blissey**
Blissey, Blissey Blissey...
From the very beginning, I cited Blissey as a pokemon that I did not want to review - to the point where one of my reasons for focusing on generally weaker pokemon was that if I covered too many "strong" pokemon, I would feel obligated to cover Blissey as well, which I was actively trying to avoid. Blissey is literally just putting an even bigger stat stick on what was already one of the top three best pokemon in the game - [Rhyperior](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1kcepls/what_if_gen_iv_evolutions_of_gen_i_pokemon_were/) at least brought Rock Wrecker to the party to improve on Rhydon in a flashier way, but Blissey has no such new moves or anything of note in comparison to Chansey other than bigger numbers.
However, something has changed since I began this series - *Chansey is no longer considered one of the top 3 best pokemon in RBY OU*. It's popularity has fallen quite a bit in the past 2 years, and while it's still really good, it's seen today as more around Starmie/Exeggutor level than Tauros/Snorlax level, and gets dropped at a frequency that would have been unheard of when I began this series. So now, the question arises: Would Blissey's stat boost over Chansey be enough to get it back to Tauros/Snorlax viability and revive the "big 3" meta? It's a question that might be worth asking, but still not one that I'm really that interested in asking. Even if Blissey's power boost is not as blatantly unnecessary as it was when Chansey was already a top dog, that still wouldn't change the fact that Blissey would be a very boring review, being barely any different from a pokemon that is *still one of the top five pokemon in RBY as it is*.
**Arceus**
Really, the only reason I didn't cover Arceus was that I wasn't interested in doing reviews that were specifically dedicated to Ubers. If I were to do an Ubers-focused version of this series, Arceus would be an obvious superstar. I probably wouldn't bother with the plates gimmick at all and just leave Arceus as solely a normal-type pokemon, but this is RBY - the normal type is all it needs! In [Reverend's video on RBY Ubers](https://youtu.be/0_iIVNV_AMA?t=936), he suggested that if Mew was a normal type, it would probably be better than Mewtwo. Arceus is a normal type with Swords Dance, Recover, Thunder Wave, basically every coverage move it could ever ask for, and 20 more points in every stat than Mew has. The only things it misses out on are Explosion and Transform, but other than that, Arceus is basically a normal type Mew that can outspeed Tauros and Starmie, which is ridiculous. Mewtwo could still go toe to toe with it, but would undeniably be playing second fiddle, basically becoming to Arceus what Mew is to Mewtwo. Meanwhile, Mew is still better than every other pokemon not named Mewtwo or Arceus, so even if it's getting overshadowed hard by Arceus, it would probably still see a lot of use. After all, why not have Mewtwo and two Mews?