What if Stunfisk was in RBY?
(This is the final entry of a weekly series. See [this post](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1hhy8d2/ksyons_rby_port_ideas_masterpost/) for information on my general methodology and links to previous entries.)
**Stunfisk**
*Ground/Electric type*
* HP: 109 * Attack: 66 * Defense: 84 * Speed: 32 * Special: 81
Moves:
* Bide * Thunder Shock * Thunderbolt * Fissure * Toxic * Take Down * Double-Edge * Rage * Thunder * Earthquake * Dig * Mimic * Double Team * Reflect * Rest * Thunder Wave * Rock Slide * Substitute * Surf
This is the 100th pokemon I have covered since I began this series almost two years ago, and I have decided that this will be my final review for the forseeable future. And what better pokemon to dedicate my final review to than *the pokemon after which this very subreddit is named*? Is it a strong pokemon? Hell no. Would it be OU in RBY? Also hell no. Stunfisk might seem kind of disappointing for a final review, but when you really think about it, doesn't a kind of shitty low-tier pokemon that might have some really weird hyperspecific niche in OU fit my idiom so much better?
Stunfisk's main party trick is that it's a ground type that can learn Thunder Wave. This is valuable because paralysis is an incredibly important status in RBY, and Thunder Wave is generally one of the most reliable ways of spreading it, so having a pokemon that can spread paralysis via Thunder Wave via being immune to your opponent's Thunder Waves gives you a major leg up in the race to get as much of your opponent's team paralyzed as possible while limiting paralysis on your own team. This specific trait is what brought [Tyranitar](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/1o8as2z/what_if_tyranitar_was_in_rby/) (who would have likely been a rock/ground type if it was in RBY, since Larvitar and Pupitar are both rock/ground and the dark type didn't exist) from an impressively strong pokemon to an *absolutely broken* one, but unlike Tyranitar, Stunfisk is not an impressively strong pokemon to begin with. Stunfisk's bulk is pretty decent, but weaknesses to both Blizzard *and* Earthquake undermine that bulk quite a bit, it only barely outspeeds Snorlax, and its offenses are quite lacking. Stunfisk also has some very conspicuous holes in its movepool, not only lacking Body Slam, but being one of the few fully-evolved Pokemon to not be able to learn Hyper Beam. I used to think that a pokemon with weak offenses could make up for it if it was good at spreading status, but that can only go so far if your opponent can just send in their own already-paralyzed Chansey and you have no way to punish that. Stunfisk's Earthquake will 3HKO Chansey and Alakazam, which *might* be enough to keep them from stonewalling your Thunder Waves, especially when you also factor in that they're paralyzed while it's very likely that you aren't. And Starmie gets 2HKOd by Stunfisk's Thunderbolt, but if your opponent's Starmie is paralyzed in the first place you're already miles ahead.
Thunder Wave is obviously mandatory, and there's very little sense in dropping Earthquake or Thunderbolt, but Stunfisk actually has a few options for its fourth move, despite its seemingly small movepool. Surf lets it deal massive damage to and potentially OHKO Rhydon, who is otherwise another major TWave blocker who threatens Stunfisk a lot. Rock Slide is Stunfisk's best move against Zapdos, who Stunfisk can actually wall pretty effectively, being immune to electric moves and only taking 12.8% at most from a non-crit Drill Peck, but Thunderbolt is also a perfectly serviceable move for Zapdos, and the advantage of Rock Slide may not be worth giving up a different fourth move unless you really need Stunfisk to be as strong vs. Zapdos as possible. And finally, as a ground type with over 400 HP, Stunfisk has the tools to take full advantage of Substitute, getting all the same benefits that Rhydon does from the move.
I could see Stunfisk's special stat going either way between it's special attack of 81 or its special defense of 99 - I went with its special attack because I tend to default to using special attack when I think it's a genuine toss-up. With 99 special, Stunfisk's Surf goes from OHKOing Rhydon about 50% of the time to a guaranteed OHKO, while Rock Slide becomes an even more marginal improvement over Thunderbolt in the Zapdos matchup, so it makes a big difference in regards to which options for Stunfisk's fourth move are more or less valuable, but it doesn't really change the fundamental strengths and weaknesses of Stunfisk all that much.
Being a TWaver who is itself immune to TWave is such a useful trait that I can see Stunfisk having a niche in basically every tier, but the pokemon outside of that is so lackluster that I can't really say which tier would become Stunfisk's "home" - the tier where Stunfisk actually becomes a staple threat and not just a weird niche pick. STAB Earthquakes off of only 66 base attack just aren't impressive in any tier, and outside of the obvious role of a TWave spammer, the utility of an electric type that's weak to water and ice moves is dubious. I could easily imagine a world where Stunfisk winds up all the way down in ZU, but I could just as easily see Stunfisk's offenses and bulk being good *enough*, in combination with its TWave access + immunity, to make it a staple in NU or PU (though UU might be asking a bit much).