I want to know Stupidpol's takes on intersectionality. Why are you for or against it either in concept or practice and how do you respond to charges of class reductionism via this concept when you try to discuss class politics?
Rule (2) here makes it explicit that intersectionality isn't welcome, but I'm willing to guess that manypeople who *identify* with the Left (Hedges often refers to 'the self-identified Left,' the implication being that many people may identify as Leftists in America but aren't in a meaningful way) probably don't know what to make of this or just react acerbically. This post is an opportunity to clarify and discuss why it's regarded with hostility.
Not to imply that I'm impartial, my brief take on intersectionality is that while it doesn't really sound like a problem (or even controversial) in theory, in actual discourse, it is de facto pretty much explicitly anti-class politics. I'm sure that is the essence of why it is right there in Rule (2).
I mean, even in theory, the concept is muddied to say the least in terms of how it is broadly understood, as its essence is to assert that there is an interaction between material politics and racial politics or whatever other kind of non-material politics/social dynamic you might imagine, but never is there a clear effort on the part of your average proponent to delineate how it is *weighted* (is it more identity? more class?), and indeed, the implication is often that identity really takes primacy; I feel this is simply wrong, and even to assert that they both have *equal* importance is also wrong and historically, economically, and politically illiterate.
I find it illustrative when these conflicts come up to try and move the focus toward actual policy goals. I often ask that people who fight for identity politics first come up with clear policies they'd demand to achieve whatever their socio-political goals are -- if they can even name them in a meaningfully specific way or without majorly infringing on constitutional rights of expression -- and compare these invariably weak responses to the laundry list of overwhelmingly critical Leftist material policy goals that would disproportionately benefit minorities, such as universal healthcare, unionization, definancialization, better wages, so on.
In brief, in day-to-day discourse, intersectionality virtually never comes up except as an attack or dismissal in response to a call for class politics because its entire purpose in the discourse in-point-of-fact is to shoot class unifying discussion and strategy down.
It is an extremely good example of a **bad faith argument** in modern politics. People who cry 'intersectionality' almost *always* **fail to** **actually incorporate a proper material analysis into their worldview**, which in my estimation is why materialists don't have a lot of respect for it (not because materialists don't care about racism, which anyone who actually read communist or socialist literature would know).