RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/subaru • … • u/Lysurgik

2012 Outback 3.6R - Recent buy, need advice

Hey everyone, about 60 days ago I bought a 2012 Outback 3.6R with 139k miles on it for about $9,000. It had an immaculate CarFax with tons of maintenance records primarily from the big Subaru dealership here in Austin. I had it inspected by my local auto shop and they gave me the all clear reporting no oil leaks and everything was in good working order, so I felt good buying it. I really wanted a 3.6R with non CVT transmission (I just don't have any experience with them and heard bad things). I verified with the dealership that all the major scheduled maintenance had been performed on time. But after driving it for a few weeks, I started to notice two things that were concerning.

​

Problem one: I notice some hard shifting when slowing down to a near stop and then accelerating again, sometimes just a slight clunk when going into second or third, sometimes you can really feel it, but its not that severe and only happens when transitioning from slowing down to accelerating.

Problem two: I also noticed that when I was driving up hills cruising at 55-60mph it feels like there is a SLIGHT chugging feeling, almost like when I've had cylinders missing in another vehicle but not nearly as severe. It also feels similar to when I had a timing belt slipping in an old 4Runner, but again not nearly as severe. This ONLY happens going uphill when im just barely on the gas. I never feel any lack of power elsewhere.

​

I took it to the Subaru Dealership and described the symptoms and left it with them. The next day they reported the following:

\- They had discovered an engine oil leak in the cam carriers and they needed to "reseal both cam carriers and caps with valve cover gaskets and front timing cover seal" ($3,250) It must not be severe because I have no oil in my driveway and cant see any evidence of a leak myself...

\- They want to replace both front lower ball joints ($600) (Im not disputing this, now that they've pointed it out I can feel they're loose)

\- Throttle body needs cleaning (could this be the

​

My total for repairs was far more than I ever expected, so I told the service advisor my story and he suggested that I sell the car and start over. He claimed that the transmission issue is benign and shouldnt get worse over time or break down. He said it's because some parts in the transmission are 'over pressurized'? He suspected that the previous owner saw these repairs coming and chose to trade in instead. I told them not to do any work at all so I could think about what I'm going to do...

​

I really love the car because the body and interior is in amazing shape. It took a lot of searching to find a 3.6R at all, and I felt like 2012 was later in the generation and had the 5EAT I thought I wanted and would be a solid car to keep and upgrade (light overlanding outfitting) over the next 5-7 years. So what do you guys think I should do? Should I sell it and just try to get another 3.6R? If so, what year would be best value for the money? I know I can get my local mechanic to do the work for way cheaper than the dealership, but is that even worth it if its always going to shift hard and feel like that? I'm just so lost and depressed over this. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!

​

TLDR: I bought a 2012 3.6R and I guess I got handed a lot of problems, should I fix them and keep it, or sell and start over?

— 0