Am I wasting my time with Subaru Advocacy? 2022 Outback limited
I'll start with I do love my car and mostly drive it around town for errands and occasional longer drives. We do 3-5 road trips a year from SF/Bay Area to LA and have about 46K on it. No real heavy or crazy driving as both of us are retired and are pretty chill. We've taken the dog to Tahoe and to Seattle in it. It's been great but.....
In 2024 there was this noise determined coming from the left side to be the CV Axel/control arm maybe cracked? Replaced under warranty. In the dealer for a week. Seemed fine after this fix though at this time we had noticed another noise and we were told it was because the tires were "cupping" due to alignment? We didn't buy new tires at that time as they still had sufficient treat and only 30K on them.
2025 noise is back, I'd say a click sound with turn to left or around 40 miles an hour. My husband called it "binding"? Anyway back into the dealer.... again problem with the Left CV axel, replaced. not charged.
June 2026-I'd been sick and my husband is driving my car and states he hears that noise again. Back to the dealer. Again it's the Left CV axel replaced. Bring it home. I drive it but I can hear the noise! My husband knowing I don't feel well says "oh wait, we can't take it back next week". NO.. So we take it back the next day. Now they keep it for a week trying to locate the issue. During this time the service rep who's helping us either quits or is fired and stops calling us with updates on the car. I have to keep calling to find out updates and that my car has been reassigned. Im told they're taking it all apart to find the noise and will need it through the weekend. They end up having the car for a week and finally it's ready for p/u and they tell us it's a loose bolt on the Crossmember support front and that's not really covered under warranty, but they'll take care of us.
My 5yr/50K is about to run out and I'm concerned after three years in a row that there's something more than the CV axel wrong here. This just doesn't add up.
I opened a case 2 weeks ago with Subaru Advocacy and they've now elevated it to a manager who called me back last week. He's being coy and saying every car is inspected off assembly and all parts they use are Subaru Parts. Maybe it's how we drive the car... which is BS. I just don't know if I should pursue this case, as if this happens again in a year then it's on us to pay for it. And if it does I'm getting rid of the car.
Thoughts?
Update: I received another call late today from SA and now I’ve been reassigned to someone else who’s now handling my case. There’s a new twist that they are investigating. It seems secondary receipt was made after our second to last visit (the day after we took the car home) and I don’t have a copy obviously. This one states the right cv axel was replaced? Which makes no sense because that’s not we were told and that’s not what my receipt states when we took the car home. And now that service representative no longer works there? Hmmmmm. He said they will be getting back to me once they can get to the bottom of this issue.