RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/subnautica • … • u/Garlayn_toji

SN 2 EULA: EU citizens, you can take action

EDIT: thank you for having clarified the situation. I am now aware that the EULA is unenforceable both in EU and in US due to the illegal nature of the terms.

When the game launched the early access, I could read the EULA and we all know how insane it is. It is also mostly illegal in the EU.

Basically, the EULA violates the following:

* Art. 5(1)(a)(b)(e) GDPR: the data collected through telemetry is described in vague and unclear terms. The Privacy Policy does not specify a maximum retention period for the data collected, in violation of the principle of storage limitation. The purposes of data processing are not stated with sufficient clarity or specificity, in violation of the principles of purpose limitation and data minimisation. * Art. 7(4) GDPR: access to the game is strictly blocked unless the consumer provides explicit consent to the game's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy simultaneously. There is no opt-out option whatsoever, and refusal results in the loss of access to a product already purchased. This situation renders the consent neither freely given nor specific, as required by Art. 7 GDPR and the EDPB Guidelines 05/2020 on consent. * Art. 82 GDPR: Section 8 of the Terms of Service limits the Company's total liability to fifty US dollars ($50) for any damage, including explicitly "loss or exposure of data." The right to compensation for damages resulting from a GDPR violation is a matter of European public policy and cannot be contractually capped or waived. * Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 (Rome I), Art. 6(2): Section 13 of the Terms imposes California law as the sole governing law. Under Rome I, such a choice of law cannot deprive a consumer of the mandatory protections afforded by the law of their country of habitual residence. The formulation "applicable local laws shall only affect these Terms to the extent required by the applicable jurisdiction" explicitly attempts to minimise the application of local law to its absolute minimum, which is precisely what Art. 6(2) prohibits. * Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Brussels I bis), Arts. 18(1) and 19: Section 13 grants exclusive jurisdiction to the courts of Contra Costa County, California. Under Brussels I bis, a consumer domiciled in an EU Member State may bring proceedings before the courts of their domicile. Any contractual clause derogating from this right prior to the dispute arising is null and void with respect to the consumer. * Directive 93/13/EEC, Annex point 1(q); French Code de la consommation, Arts. L. 212-1 and R. 212-2(10°): Section 11 imposes mandatory individual arbitration in San Ramon, California, conducted in English under California state law, and requires consumers to waive their right to have their claims decided by a judge or jury. Section 14 further prohibits participation in any class or representative action. The combined effect of Sections 11 and 14 is the complete suppression of any effective legal remedy for consumers, which constitutes an unfair term under both the Directive and French consumer law. Under French law (Code de procédure civile, Art. 2061), arbitration clauses are unenforceable against consumers in the absence of a post-dispute agreement. * Directive 2011/83/EU, Art. 16; French Code de la consommation, Art. L. 221-18: Section 9 states that the Company is not obligated to issue any refunds. This broad exclusion of refunds is contrary to the mandatory 14-day right of withdrawal applicable to online purchases of digital content under EU law. * Directive 2019/770/EU, Arts. 14 and 19; French Code civil, Art. 1171: Section 9 grants the Company the right to terminate access without prior notice, while simultaneously denying any refund. Section 4 further allows the Company to modify or restrict access "without notice and in its sole discretion." These clauses create a significant imbalance between the parties' rights and obligations to the detriment of the consumer.

I know Unknown Worlds is looking into the EULA so I have hope that it could change. On my side, I emailed Krafton on May 16th to notice them of the mentioned violations and gave them 30 days to change it (honestly they won't) and if they don't I will file formal complaints to:

* "Commission Nationale de l'Informatique et des Libertés" (CNIL) and "Direction Générale de la Concurrence, de la Consommation et de la Répression des Fraudes" (DGCCRF) in France, * the European Consumers Center (ECC) of France, find yours at [https://www.eccnet.eu/](https://www.eccnet.eu/).

EU citizens, you should have similar authorities in your countries, so if like me you want the EULA change to respect your rights, take action, apply pressure. Krafton already had issues with EU in the past, it can happen again.

— 0