RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/subnautica • … • u/TrueBlueCorvid

[Spoilers] Everything Wrong with That Subnautica Game Theory Video

I've seen so many posts asking why [this video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETj8kP0rj0o) is getting hate, so hopefully making this response its own post will make it easier to find. When the video came out, [I wrote a reply on one of the posts here](https://www.reddit.com/r/subnautica/comments/qoztpp/comment/hjr2to1/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3). This is an expanded version of that reply, now with links! I hope it helps! Sorry if I'm a little wordy.

***TL;DR:*** **The video is not about Subnautica. It's an environmental awareness PSA that's written in a deliberately antagonizing way in order to provoke engagement.**

# Me vs. Game Theory

**No hate, just facts.** I don't know this "MatPat" guy at all. I've never heard of him before now. I don't watch his videos. I don't have any opinions on him personally. I hope he's having a nice day and when I'm done writing this I will resume not thinking about him ever.

# Game Theory vs. Lore

All of the following major points made in the Game Theory video are directly contradicted by the lore in the game (which the video claims to have done a "deep dive" into.)

**Game Theory: The Aurora should have destroyed everything when it crashed.**

The Aurora didn't just fall out of the sky. The fact that everything isn't obliterated is not an oversight. >!Keen's logs show the captain staying aboard the ship so that he could pilot it as long as possible to minimize the damage. In his broadcast, he says that he's attempting "a controlled descent," and says the survivors will need the ship (specifically its long-range comms) intact to contact Alterra for rescue.!< ([relevant logs on the wiki](https://subnautica.fandom.com/wiki/Second_Officer_Keen#Lifepod_19_Second_Officer_Keen.27s_Voicelog))

**Game Theory: The Aurora's crash dumped plastic waste into the ocean.**

There's no evidence that Alterra uses non-biodegradable fossil fuel Earth plastics anywhere in Subnautica, to my knowledge. None of the items in the game show any parts that are definitely plastic and plastic is not required for any crafting in the game because plastic does not exist as a crafting material in Subnautica. Items that could reasonably come in plastic packaging (like nutrient blocks and water bottles) do not leave any such packaging behind when consumed.

(I want to be clear: I'm talking about *plastic waste* because the Game theory video goes on at length about it. I don't object at all to the idea that the debris from the Aurora -- and other crashes -- *in general* are probably detrimental to the environment on 4546b. Though it is kind of weird to frame this as the player's -- or even the protagonist's -- fault.)

**Game Theory: The explosion of the Aurora's drive core caused nuclear fallout.**

The part of the ship that exploded early in the game was its dark-matter ion drive core, not a nuclear reactor. It's possible that the "radiation" that exists in the game is not nuclear radiation at all, but something else. Furthermore, the Aurora is equipped with technology to contain and remove that radiation. >!(I can't find the line on the wiki, but once the breaches in the drive core are repaired, the PDA says: "Attention: High-energy particle containment field restored. Auto-decontamination sequence initiated.")!< ([relevant data bank entries on the wiki](https://subnautica.fandom.com/wiki/Aurora#Data_Bank_Entries))

The Aurora *was* carrying prefabricated nuclear reactors for use at its destination -- however, we only ever find pieces of the reactor machinery, and never any reactor rods, which may suggest that any such fuel was expected to be fabricated on-site.

# Game Theory vs. The Devs/Community

This video is produced in such a way to deliberately make people angry as a way to drive engagement and exploit YouTube's algorithm for more views. (That's just the way of the internet right now; I'll leave discussion of the effects of that to more relevant communities.) I say this because **I want to ask people to remember that the video's combative tone is a deliberate choice that's been made to get attention, not a personal attack.** (It's also why there's no reason to expect that the video will be taken down or that there will be an apology. The backlash isn't punishment, it's fuel.)

What I want to set the record straight on is the running implication that the devs and the players didn't think about or didn't care about the environmental issues that the video raises.

This isn't true!

One of my favorite stories to come out of Subnautica's development is that early access players cared so much about the environment in the game that the devs built in a side-quest where it's addressed so that players can fix it. ([Jonas Boetel of Unknown Worlds Entertainment mentions this very briefly in the GDC Subnautica postmortem, linked here.](https://youtu.be/fkjY_R7zQsM?t=1736))

The associated achievement for completing that side-quest is called *"Extinction Event Avoided"* \-- which conveniently and concisely debunks that Game Theory video's big premise that by crashing into 4546b, we have "killed" the planet.

# Game Theory vs. Game Design

And here we get into some of the more weird, philosophical problems I have with this video. Feel free to skip this bit if you already understand the concept of "it's a game, it doesn't have to be realistic," but I do think I'll talk about it a little!

**Video games represent life in an** ***abstract,*** **not** ***exact*** **way.**

This is a necessity of the medium -- representing things with exact realism simply isn't possible with today's technology, and it probably never will be. This reality needs to be taken into consideration when critiquing whether parts of a game accurately represent things in the real world.

"Is this realistic?" is not really a useful metric. Does it represent what it's seeking to represent in a meaningful way? What do the abstractions inherent in the mechanics of the game imply? Does it obstruct the player's ability to play or have fun?

The Game Theory video throws around a lot of numbers, but they're really for the sake of its goal as an environmental PSA. They don't have anything to do with the game, and they're mostly not valid points of game design critique even if they're technically accurate.

For example, the ten kilometer radius of damage that the Aurora "should have caused" is largely irrelevant because a map that would accommodate a crash zone of that size (more than ten times the size of the actual Subnautica map) is simply not feasible to expect game developers to create by hand or players to efficiently travel around.

# In conclusion...

I think we can consider this "theory" debunked! I hope you enjoyed this read -- especially because there was so much of it!

**In the spirit of this all** ***really*** **being about environmental awareness, I'll leave you with these final thoughts:**

The fictional world of 4546b is not doomed because real people cared about it. Real people care about our real world, too. While we can all do our part in things like recycling and donating to (and participating in) cleanup efforts... like in Subnautica, the causes of environmental harm are largely huge corporations and not individuals.

Like in Subnautica, the single best way we have to help fix things is by speaking out. Find trustworthy sources of information and stay informed. Vote for leadership that takes global climate change seriously. Contact the people who make policy on your behalf and tell them the environment matters to you.

Like in Subnautica, the world is not doomed. The worst lie ever told about the damage humanity has done to our world is that we can't fix it. *We can.*

**Edit:** Fixed some formatting. Thanks for your patience, I'm a lil new to Reddit. :3

— 0