RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/sudoku • … • u/alcheoii

The way to identify or verify fishes as naked sets and hidden sets

Recently I've been thinking about fishes like x-wings, swordfish etc. that it will contain the candidates in certain rows or columns. Then I realized that if I write down the row/column of candidates, they will show up as the naked sets. Look at the example of 9 candidates here: if you look at the 3rd column there are the 9 candidates appearing in r7 and r8. Same goes for the 5th column with r1 and r8 and also the 8th column with r1 and r7.

![img](mg3h6qsfvn4e1)

If you are familiar with the naked triple, you can spot swordfish easily this way with 78 18 and 17!

Anyway, when I checked whether people have noticed this technique before, it seems that someone already did back in 2005-2006 : [a new (?) view of fish (naked or hidden) : Advanced solving techniques](http://forum.enjoysudoku.com/a-new-view-of-fish-naked-or-hidden-t5017.html) and he also pointed out that the corresponding rows also form the hidden triple too. (in this case 58 38 35)

However, I would like to illustrate this technique again because it is not very well known and some people are still struggling to find fishes.

— 0