The Piantas are hoarding the Shines
This is just me being silly but like the citizens of Isle Delphino are whining and crying so much bc the Shines left, you know? And yes, granted I’ll give that the majority of them are. Mario has to get them back by cleaning, fighting baddies, etc. but there’s at LEAST 30 of them sitting in the possession of some random people on the island! There’s 2 of them just sitting behind locked doors that SOME resistant obviously has the key to. There’s 2 that the shop keep guy is hoarding and gives to Mario after Mario breaks boxes, and the Blue Coin vendor guy has TWENTY FOUR ALL TO HIMSELF. If they’re hurting for Shines so badly, why didn’t they use those ones? lol