RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/supersmashbros • … • u/Low_Confidence2479

Good representation of source material in movesets...sadly called "bad" out of spite by fans

There're some good representations in movesets that get slandered out of spite. The reasons for the spite vary, but I think most of it comes from the competitive scene just...not agreeing from a gameplay standpoint, regardless of the source material (meaning they latch onto any inconsistency to scream for any change).

Sometimes though, it's the fans themselves from the original game being nitpicky. That's OK. Everyone can have opinions, but calling them overall "bad" is too much.

Because of this, I decide to go and look at some fighters I know of that get some slander about the representation that I find a little unfair or straight up spiteful. Let's do it.

Mega Man: some fans are upset about his animations (or rather, his personality, or lack there of), and that's...fair. But to be fair, the personality was mostly relegated to VERY few cutscenes in some games. When it comes to Mega Man in gameplay...we got exactly that in Smash. Other people also complain about how the representation overrelies on the NES games...and that's fair...but keep this in mind. This was an era where the most recent game was Mega Man 10, and both it and 9 are based heavily on 2 (which is why Mega Man got nerfed compared to games after 3). On top of that, 7 and 8 got shafted by fans when they came out due to the popularity of the X series (taking years until these games got accepted as they are, good Mega Man games). We're lucky that despite all that, Mega Man got moves from other games, as well as the slide and buster, and even the final smash starts as a move from 9 only to involve every single protagonist. Relaxalax said it best when he compared Smash Mega Man to MvC Mega Man. MvC adapted Mega Man into a fighting game...while Smash adapted a fighting game for Mega Man. Mega Man is no stranger to fighting games, but the gameplay from him differs in that environment. Smash is the closest we have to a fighting game where Mega Man plays HIS game.

Bayonetta: people hated Bayonetta and it's players to an unhealthy degree back in Smash 4. And some of the hate got directed to the design, mentioning Bayonetta's lack of other weapons is not faithful, so she's not even from her game...what?...the combos and witch time is all Bayonetta needed to be herself, and fans will likely agree.

Hero: this one...before launch and during the first week, people treated him like Bayonetta's second coming...that ended up not being the case but even to this day people hate him. The random Smash attack critical hits seemed to be too much for some people and some even requested these attacks to straight up miss like in some RPGs...while not a bad idea, it would look jarring if an attack went through an opponent and did nothing like an RPG, so I guess we need better animations than that. Another thing is the spells. The usage of MP seems universally liked, though the command selection is controversial, mainly because of the randomness it brings with it. While RPGs generally don't do that, it was a good compromise for Smash, and thanks to it, Hero has the most special moves than any other fighter (even Sakurai said so) except MAYBE Kirby. One complain I can agree on though and it seems so did the developers is the lack of icons on the menu. Why do I say the developers agree? Judging by the first trailers and even Sakurai's presentation, Hero was initially made to have a menu similar to the one from classic DQ games (use DS versions for reference), yet in-game got menu that looks more like 11. 11 has icons, 7 and below don't. Seems change was done at last moment...no time for icons.

Min Min: alright, sure, not being able to attack the ARMs is very unlike...ARMS...I get that. That being said, the design literally wouldn't work if it was like that given rushdowns would have a field day with her that way and she already struggles with them. Min Min is still a pretty faithful representation of ARMS...for better or worse.

Steve: for all the hate people have for him...the thing they decided to complain from the source material is a nitpick. Basically Steve in Smash can create blocks in midair, something that in Minecraft shouldn't be possible unless you use creative move to make the air be the floor. The thing is, much like Min Min, his design wouldn't work without that. We have to account not just on stages like Battlefield and Final Destination, but also the other 114 stages in the game. Creating blocks from the ground would range from annoying to almost impossible in some wacky stages, plus it limits the creativity (you know, Minecraft's thing). He's still faithful elsewhere.

Joker: he's very...divisive...some people love his representation...others clearly don't. I think the issue with Joker is that he doesn't represent SMT or even Persona as a whole...just Persona 5. He only has a single Persona and most of his moves are taken from the UI animations and the opening...perfect for Joker...disservice for any other protagonist in Persona and SMT. And I think that's just perfect because, like Joker in Smash, Persona 5 is NOT like the other games in a lot of stuff. SMT fans and Persona fans seem to be two different groups of fans. And people who have Persona 5 as their favourite is generally not too fond of the other games or viceversa.

Pac-Man: here we have one I hesitated to put on the list. Look, I can understand where most of the other characters' complaints come from. But Pac-Man is a case where I share some of the sentiment...yet I also think it was for the best. Here's the thing, people mention Pac-Man World as the perfect place to draw a moveset from, but Pac-Man isn't a platforming icon (ok, maybe it is, but more importantly...)...he's an arcade icon. It's the same reason people preferred the Pac-Maze stage over Pac-Land...one is clearly more symbolic with Pac-Man than the other. But that classic arcade game, in order to be in that moveset, they got creative with the references.

Kazuya: another Bamco character. This one got probably the biggest amount of freebies in the transition from his game to Smash, and that's because of what Sakurai said, Tekken and Smash don't work even remotely similar. They tried to make him as faithful to play as possible while overcompensating elsewhere...and sure they did.

Cloud: I almost didn't put him on the list, but I saw people upset at the nerf he got when he went from Smash 4 to Ultimate, being the timer on the limit breakers. Ignoring the problems the lack of a timer caused in Smash 4, the limit attacks don't work like how Cloud uses them in Smash. They're doing a similar approach Joker would take later, being using specials regardless of any mana, but make them powerful with said mana available (OK, I know neither case is technically mana, but in context, it kinda helps explaining it). Cloud did it before Joker, which is why he got all the flack at first. With materia being reserved for a stage, I think Cloud moveset is a well rep.

Snake: much like Kazuya, he got a lot of freebies...but for other reasons. The age rating systems have problems with firearms...so they had to give Snake a lot of explosives instead. For a stealth icon, it's a bit silly. They also decided to make Smash Snake a hybrid of Solid and Naked, which caused some controversy at first. Despite this, Snake got a very good representation. He doesn't play as close to his game as someone like Kazuya tries to do (even though he does have a few moves and all weapons he uses are in Metal Gear), but the animations are as close to Metal Gear as possible...and as a consolation prize...codec calls...need I say more?

It's OK to hate a character design competitively, but holding onto a minor inconsistency for the sake of it, to me, seems silly. What do you think? Let me know below.

— 0