Trump v. CASA. How would a hypothetical assenting ruling have worked in practice?
I am still reading through the whole decision with intent, instead of the quick scan through I normally do to start. I know this is a contentious ruling, and I'm following the other threads here about it with interest. This question is so what of a hypothetical, based on what an assenting ruling would have looked like.
At it's core, this seems like a jurisdictional problem. Consider an Executive Order that runs afoul of two individuals that happen to live in separate districts. They each pursue litigation, but their federal district courts rule differently. So, in one district a judge rules in favor of the plaintiff, and in the other district a judge rules in favor of the government. Which one is deemed to have jurisdictional authority to apply outside of it's original jurisdiction? Would we just have to assume that the ruling the determines an EO or part of an EO is unconstitutional should be the prevailing ruling?
I don't want to argue the merits of the case at hand, or whether or not it is moral. I am just interest in discussing how an opposing decision would be carried out in practice. Also, I suppose I am curious if there is any precedent of these situations occuring in the past that have been resolved a certain way that is no longer possible?