RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/supremecourt • … • u/whats_a_quasar

7th Circuit splits 3 ways on administration's mandatory immigration detention policy: 1 would reject it, 1 would accept it, 1 does not reach it

This Seventh Circuit case was a dispute about adherence to a consent decree between DHS and a group of Illinois plaintiffs. The case touches on the administration's mandatory immigration detention policy but, in a split outcome, there is no majority on its legality. Judge Lee, writing the main opinion, would have rejected the policy. Judge Pryor concurs in part and in the judgment, but does not join the section of Lee's opinion rejecting the policy. Judge Kirsch, dissenting, would have affirmed it.

The question is whether [8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2)(A)](https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title8-section1225&num=0&edition=prelim) authorizes the detention without bail of any alien present in the US who was not admitted, or only recent entrants or aliens detained near the border. The administration takes the first position, which differs from previous policy and has produced [thousands of habeas cases](https://www.politico.com/news/2026/02/18/trump-judges-immigration-detention-00784614) across the country. This case is the fourth one in which appeals court judges have addressed the issue, but was about a consent decree rather than an appeal of a habeas case. The complicated procedural posture muddied the outcome: Judge Pryor deemed that DHS had waived that argument and did not reach the question

The previous circuit rulings are:

* [Second Circuit, rejects the policy](https://www.reddit.com/r/supremecourt/comments/1sy4khc/trumps_stance_on_noncitizen_detention_rejected_by/) (April 28) * [Eigth Circuit, affirms the policy](https://www.reddit.com/r/supremecourt/comments/1s3fb94/ca8_joins_ca5_noncitizens_apprehended_inside_the/) (March 25) * [Fifth Circuit, affirms the policy](https://www.reddit.com/r/supremecourt/comments/1qy2pbs/5th_circuit_rules_in_favor_of_policy_to_expand/) (February 6)

~~This is the last circuit case on the mandatory detention policy that I was following~~ (First Circuit panel [heard oral arguments ](https://bsky.app/profile/rparloff.bsky.social/post/3ml4igjtljs26)on a relevant case on Monday actually), and it though it didn't rule on the policy, IMO it is further evidence of disagreement within the circuit courts. SCOTUS will very likely resolve this circuit split.

— 0