RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/survivor • … • u/abovethesink

Which season would be the most likely to have the same winner if replayed starting today?

If every season was replayed with the exact same cast as they exist today, which season would be the most likely to see the same winner?

All starting tribes, swap points, merge points, jury size, challenges, rewards, number of idols, etc would be exactly the same. Anything randomized, like which buff is drawn on a swap, will have different random outcomes. The now older cast members will be making new decisions too, of course.

If someone is sadly deceased, then their tribe is down one to start. Everyone is in the current physical and mental state that they are in as of midnight, May 4th 2025. Everyone alive will be present and playing to the best of their abilities. They will have all the life experiences they really have had and will of course remember how it went the first time.

Which winner from which season would be the most likely to turn around and win again?

— 0