New Era: Without Firemaking
As we saw recently with 50, firemaking ain't going anywhere. Production loves it, the general audience is in favor of it, its a permanent part of the game. While its provided some fun moments, I've increasingly felt it ultimately stifles gameplay in the end and can allow a solid trio or foursome to play without ever really having to turn on one another. Our 4th Placers aren't voted out anymore, they get to leave more amicably in competition, which then also informs their decision making on the Jury. In hand with that, the most dangerous players have to go even earlier so they can't be allowed to save themselves in fire. So I wanted to see what the New Era looked like without that. Out of 10 New Era seasons, how often does that effect the winner?
* 41 - Xander wins Immunity, he sends DeShawn and Heather to fire where Heather loses. His reasoning was he didn't want Erika to add fire to her resume. Without that, I'm guessing the three just gets together and takes out Erika. Xander was never winning, so its between DeShawn and Heather now. I kinda think Heather gets the votes Erika got? So new winner in Heather * 42 - Romeo wins Immunity, sending Jonathan and Mike to fire where Mike wins. With Maryanne still on no ones radar, I think Mike is the consensus vote here and goes in 4th now. Jonathan is at the end, but it doesn't matter and Maryanne still pulls it off. * 43 - Cassidy wins Immunity, sending Gabler and Jesse to fire to take out Jesse. This is a big one because without fire, I don't know if Jesse moves on Cody at 6, and not doing that changes the whole game. But assuming it still plays out the same, Jesse goes at 4 still. But without fire on his resume, can Gabler still pull the win? I'm inclined to lean yes, so a still controversial win in Gabler. * 44 - Heidi wins Immunity, sending herself to fire to take out Carson, leading to the Yam Yam win. This one is tricky, one of the Tika 3 was always winning at this point. I'm not sure if Heidi could've gotten Yam Yam and Carolyn to take out Carson in a consensus vote, so I think we might get a tie and firemaking anyway, but between Carson and possibly Yam Yam. Whoever wins this wins the season. * 45 - Dee wins Immunity, sends Jake and Katurah to fire, Katurah goes. This one is interesting again because of how messy Jake and Katurah were. Dee and Austin likely vote Katurah. Even though its in Jakes interest to do so as well, he always swung for the fences, so its not impossible he tries to get Austin out. And there's a non zero chance Katurah tries to take out Jake here. So we've got a possibility of Austin and Katurah in fire. I'm inclined to think Katurah still goes here no matter what, but if there's a world its Jake and its Katurah vs Dee vs Austin in the F3, that could've been interesting * 46 - Ben wins Immunity, Liz and Kenzie go to fire, Kenzie wins, robbing Liz of her clean sweep victory. This one's tricky because the Ben win comes out of nowhere. He wanted Liz out, whereas I think Liz and Kenzie would lead a charge on Charlie. So I think we're definitely getting fire here between Liz and Charlie. If Liz wins, I think Kenzie still wins. If its Charlie, I'm curious if that changes anything, especially in regards to Maria. * 47 - Rachel wins, sending Sam and Teeny to fire. Sam is able to save himself one last time but still can't win against Rachel. This one is actually boring because with no fire, Sam easily goes here, and Rachel sweeps the Jury since she's against Sue and Teeny. * 48 - Kyle wins, sending Eva and Kamilla to fire, where Kamilla goes gracefully and ultimately helps get Kyle the win at FTC. I really want to see this version because with no fire, Kyle's not able to diplomatically remove Kamilla, its a consensus vote instead, and I wonder if Kamilla still does what she does for him at the end. * 49 - Sophi B wins, making Rizo and Savannah face off, where Savannah pulls it off and then wins. So this is interesting as well because despite her earlier blunder wit hthe KiP, Sophi clearly knows its a mistake to sit next to both of her trio in the end. Rizo and Savannah likely think its an easy Sage vote, Sophi surprises and forces a tie with fire between Sage and Savannah this time. If Savannah goes here, does Rizo pull it out? Does Sophi? Possibilities * 50 - Aubry wins, Rizo faces Jonathan, Jonathan wins but still loses to Aubry. I don't think anything changes. Rizo goes as a vote, same win for Aubry.
What'd I get right? What I'd get wrong? What season did you most want to see play out with a vote?