RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/survivor • … • u/Pretend_Wonder1072

Francesca Hogi is unfairly maligned and shouldn't be included in "worst ever" conversations [High Effort Post]

TL;DR—Francesca should not be in the conversation for worst ever Survivor contestant simply for her 2x First Boot status, in a world (a) where no other first boot has come back for a returnee season and (b) where hundreds of castaways have been immune from first boot status through no accomplishment of their own. While you can surely identify flaws and missteps in her Redemption Island game, you can just as easily identify how Francesca got unlucky at almost every turn.

——————

In a world where she is the only first boot to come back for a returnee season, it’s unfair to cite “two-time first boot” as an argument for Francesca being “worse” at Survivor than other first boots. Any first-boot brought back alongside finalists and jury members is necessarily going to be dead-in-the-water. There’s no opportunity for in-roads when you’re the least socially connected tribemate outside the game, when other players likely harbor some “Why the fuck is she here?” resentment towards you, and when—frankly—it’s really funny for you to be voted out first.

I mean, you can take-or-leave my arguments for why she had no shot on Caramoan, but at the end of the day I think it’s disingenuous to cite her lone status in a group where she’s the only possible member—there’ve been 49 first boots in Survivor history, and people she’s the only one who would go first twice! Not singin’ Wanda from Palau, or “Vote for me” Zane, or vapeless Hannah Rose.

I also think that her Redemption Island first-boot status is not an especially bad one—

* She’s intelligent, and if you’ve ever heard her speak or met her can attest that she’s also incredibly kind and charismatic—she originally applied for Amazing Race, but CBS moved her to Survivor because they liked her so much but thought her TAR partner was a dud. * On paper, she is a threat. She was put on a tribe with Boston Rob, someone famously better-than-most at identifying and removing threats. She was not under Rob‘s influence, and he identified that quickly. * She butted heads with certified-nutso Phillip, who Boston Rob also immediately pegged as someone he wants to bring to the end—further positioning her against a Survivor legend, which is not an easy position from which to recover. * Her alliance member mishandled the info around her idol, further antagonizing Phillip. * She was voted out on a vote split to avoid an idol play! It wasn’t unanimous, it wasn’t because of one singular what-are-you-doing faux pas—if Phillip had thrown his rogue vote on Kristina instead of Francesca, we wouldn’t even be having this conversation. The voting confessionals for the votes against her are Boston Rob remarking on how easy it is to play with first-timers, Grant saying he’s voting her to keep his word to Boston Rob, Matt saying the same thing and adding that Phillip is a goat, and Phillip.

Now, I know what you’re thinking. I know the counterarguments—

1. On Survivor, you have to hide your intelligence and charisma to an extent. 2. It was a misplay to call attention to herself/distance herself from Rob and Russell from the jump by calling them troublemakers sizing up their prey. 3. It was a misplay to antagonize Phillip so early (“antagonize” for lack of a better word—she was just someone who didn’t pretend to buy into his schtick) 4. Kristina and Phillip were admittedly (at least in hindsight) poor choices for alliance members. 5. She put her foot in her mouth at tribal.

All valid points! I’m not trying to say Francesca is a ”good“ survivor player, just that she isn’t as bad as people think/say. Addressing the counterarguments above, though:

1. This is a very fair point, and relates to Rob’s “You amateurs don’t know when to shut up“ voting confessional. The main thing I have to say here is that she is far from the only castaway to have “failed to manage threat level” as a fatal flaw. I also imagine some of you will object to the assertion that her “threat level” was a contributing factor to her vote-out, but I think it’s valid to mention based on Matt’s voting confessional and her positioning opposite obvious-goat Phillip. I’d also mention that the “lay low at the start” metastrategy is a fairly recent development in Survivor game theory. 2. Again—not the only person to make this mistake! Emily Flippen made this mistake in 46, but was given a chance to recover by Hannah’s quit and Kaleb’s compassion. Christine made this mistake the very next season and only avoided Francesca’s fate because Semhar couldn’t land a coconut in a net. (You may also cite “challenge ability” here wrt Redemption Island, but I’d point out that Francesca performed surprisingly well in the first Caramoan challenge, if memory serves) 3. Funnily enough, this is another mistake that Emily also made to an extent in her first episode, when she clearly had a superiority complex and couldn’t play along with ancient alien talk. Now, you might be thinking, “Who cares? What’s your point?” My point is that a last-second quit is the difference between Emily having a reputation as arguably the worst new era player and having a reputation as a scrappy, adaptable, fun returnee. 4. Again, another valid criticism, and again my point is that this is an extremely common misstep for Survivor players—far from something that makes Francesca a uniquely bad player. 5. See above! Once again, refer to “Emily Flippen”

I imagine some of you are bristling at my use of what-ifs and hypotheticals here—we don’t and can’t know what would’ve happened if things were different! But we can identify things that were out of her control and can engage in some idle speculation (it won’t hurt). Sometimes the flaws in Francesca’s game are death knells, and other times they aren’t—that comes down to who else is on your tribe.

Ask yourself: what if Russell had gone to Ometepe instead of Rob? What if Francesca and Phillip started on opposite tribes? What if it were a regular newbie season without legend captains? What if, like Emily Flippen, Francesca had been saved by a last-second quit? What if Ometepe had won the first immunity challenge? What if Kristina hadn’t found the idol?

Obviously, the ultimate answers to those questions is “I don’t know.” But that’s my point! I feel I’ve demonstrated that there are enough variables and inflection points to where we cannot at all predict how Francesca’s Survivor career would’ve played out if even one 50/50 random draw before the game began went the other way. But that’s not the case for the other people commonly cited as bad players:

* Hannah Rose was in an okay position—we have no reason to assume she wouldn’t be a first boot quit in every season. * You could stick Brandon Donlon on any tribe in any season and he’d still be an incredible challenge liability. * Wanda from Palau would gratingly sing during any marooning

And that’s not even to mention players like Phillip (or even someone like Owen Knight), who would be hardpressed (if not completely unable) to win a FTC against almost anyone.

If you wiped every castaway’s memory and simulated a large sample size of Survivor games with Francesca, I feel confident that she would not be first boot in the vast majority of those games (I mean, it’s a numbers game at that point. She’d end up with tribal immunity around half the time!). Similarly, I think if you simulated Survivor games where every castaway is even a tangential “worst Survivor player ever” candidate—Debb, Wanda, Wendy Jo, Zane, Hannah Rose, Brandon, Jelinsky, Bhanu, etc—Francesca would come out looking like Boston Rob did in Redemption Island.

That’s it. Probably not as unpopular an opinion as I think it is, but I had fun writing this while my boss thinks I’m working.

To help continue the conversation: I think that in general the Survivor fandom is overly results-focused and does not take luck into account as much as it should. While I am a firm believer that the winner of a season is necessarily/inherently the most deserving (and there's no real such thing as a robbed finalist or an unfairly bitter jury), I think it would behoove the discussions here if everyone were able to acknowledge the sheer amount of random chance that affects every game, win or lose. How many challenges have been won by a gust of wind, by an opponent's momentary lapse in focus, or by a rock draw? Obviously there's skill in how you put yourself into those situations and capitalize on them when they arise, but still: at the end of the day, every Survivor player has had the outcome of their game affected (positively or negatively) by something out of their control. And while it's easy to shrug, say "Tough shit," and argue that that outside event should've been handled differently, I think fans can often lose sight of the simple fact that every winner has benefited from significant luck in one way or another.

— 0