RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/survivor • … • u/GammaEmerald

A counter argument to another thread re: the three tribe format

So this was originally a comment in another thread but reddit ate it and I can’t find that thread now so here goes:

I think complaining about the three tribe format causing disaster tribes in new-era seasons is misleading. Let’s go over every pre-41 season with 3 starting tribes:

All-Stars - Saboga was a hot mess

Philippines - Matsing went 0-4 in challenges

Cagayan - had the infamous Luzon tribe

Worlds Apart - can’t remember too well but the Nagarote (No Collar) tribe is the closest I think

Kaoh Rong - To Tang (Brawn) tribe was decisively a mess

HHH - the Yawa (Hustler iirc) tribe was the worst pre-swap

I rest my case. The problem the New Era had was the fact it never had a tribe dissolution iirc. So if a tribe is exhausted, then tough nuts. It also prevents natural integration with the other tribes like was seen in All-Stars and Philippines. So while I do think the New Era-three tribe format is bad, it’s not because of disaster tribes. It’s because those dumpster fires keep burning until in some cases nothing remains.

— 0