RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/survivor • … • u/SurvivorCT

There may never be another Survivor player older than Jeff Probst

Had a realization today that it is highly unlikely we'll ever have a season going forward in which Jeff is younger than any member of the cast. The first time Jeff was the oldest on-camera person of a season was in Cagayan, ahead of Trish by four years. Since then, Jeff has been the oldest in six more seasons; MvGX, HvHvH, GI, EoE, WaW, and 41. While many of these were known for having young casts (five of them had their oldest player under 50), the fact remains that this list will only continue to grow. Jeff turned 60 last month, and Survivor has historically been extremely reluctant to cast players over 60.

Only 12 (13 if you count Rudy twice) players 60 and up have ever been cast, and only three of those were in the past 20 seasons. And it's not as if there's much impetus for them to cast anyone 60+ based on performance. Of the over-60s they've cast, only half of them survived more than one tribal. The remaining six include Rudy Boesch, Jake Billingsley, Dan Lembo, "Tarzan" Smith, Joe del Campo, and Tom Laidlaw. Not exactly the most inspiring bunch. And of the two most recent over-60s, one had to be medivacced. The most recent, Tom, was one of the safest picks possible for his age, as a former athlete who was still in good shape and only barely scrapes into the 60+ group by being 60 at time of filming.

I think it's clear from recent casting trends that Survivor is wary of pushing the envelope with older players, which means the odds of a newbie over 60 seem extremely slim, when they no doubt have plenty of late 40s-mid 50s options that offer the presumed pros (conflict with younger players, relatability to parents in the audience, etc.) without the negatives of older players that will frequently become liabilities.

And considering Jeff's announcement that pre-40 players might not be back anytime soon, the outside chance at a returnee over 60 is shrinking quickly. There are 72 living former players older than Jeff, but how many of those are realistic to be brought back?

I think it's safe to rule out anyone over 65, unless they're in excellent shape. But it's likely a moot point since I don't think a single player over 62 has even a fraction of a percent chance of returning. The short list of players that *could* have even a faint shot, either because production has previously demonstrated an interest in having them back (whether by actually bringing them back or by including them on the Second Chances ballot) or because they played recently and are relatively fresh in people's minds.

That shortlist includes: Sue Hawk, Richard Hatch, Tina Wesson, Teresa Cooper, Terry Deitz, Troyzan Robertson, Keith Nale, Carolyn Rivera, Natalie Cole, and Janet Carbin.

Of that shortlist, I think it is pretty safe to assume that none of the previous returnees are coming back. They have likely run their course and/or lost public and production support. As nice as it might be to see Terry get another shot after his unfortunate circumstances, it seems incredibly unlikely. By the time season 50, the most likely candidate for a future "Legends" theme, rolls around, Tina will almost certainly be out of the running. Her WaW snub is probably the end of the line.

For the second-timers, T-Bird and Carolyn weren't voted for by the public, which seems pretty damning to their chances. And Carolyn's former recency bias has certainly evaporated 11 seasons later.

Which leaves us with Napalm Natalie and Janet. As much as Natalie is hyped up as a potential Villain and Janet as a potential Hero, let's be realistic here...there are bigger, better, younger names out there, and each passing season further dilutes their likelihood to return. Neither is a lock on the level of your Shans or Christians. And if there's one thing Survivor hates casting more than over 60s in general, it's over-60s women (shout-out to Gillian and Sonja as the only members of this group).

And here's where this lengthy diatribe actually gets to the point of making a point. It is very probable that Tom and Janet will be the last players ever to be cast, new or returning, to be older than Jeff. And that's a strange situation to be in, considering how pivotal Jeff is in every conceivable aspect of the show. Probst has already been called out-of-touch on everything from social issues to what fans want. How much worse will these problems become when Jeff has a decade or more on future seasons' oldest contestants?

EDIT: Included Sonja when counting up the over-60 players but only mentioned Gillian for women over 60.

— 0