RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/synology • … • u/BrotaryEngine

Help needed understanding SHR expansion rules for move to DS1621+

I've got a DS1512+ with 2 - 8TB drives and 3 - 3TB drives. I'm trying to move to a DS1621+ and I'd like to move most of the old drives into the new unit, but also add 2 - 14TB drives, so the new unit would have 2 - 8TB, 2 - 3TB, and 2 - 14TB. I want to do this with both units up and running, and what I'd like to do is this:

1. Fill new unit with 2 - 14TB and 4 - 1TB as "placeholder" drives 2. Copy data over from old unit 3. Take old unit offline 4. Move 3 TB drives into new unit, replacing placeholders, waiting for a rebuild after each 5. Move 8 TB drives into new unit, replacing placeholders, waiting for a rebuild after each

The problem is that the Synology documentation seems to indicate that steps 4 & 5 are "illegal" since those drives would be smaller than the 14TB drives already in the array. On the other hand, I tested a similar scenario with an array of 3TB, 1TB, and 320GB then replaced the 320GB with a 1TB and it expanded with no issues.

So, is my plan feasible? Are there any major downsides to doing it this way?

— 0