RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/synthesizers • … • u/Potatonauts

Minilogue+SineVibes' SVF vs. OG Minilogue, opinions?

Was looking at getting a Minilogue, can't decide which to get. I've been looking all over the web and YT for days, but people seem to be allergic to comparing like-for-like sounds between the two synths, and every comparison I've seen is people only owning one and BS'ing what they think about the other, or having both but making different patches on either to showcase 'character' rather than objective oscillator and filter differences. Don't get me wrong--the end goal is always the character and vibe, but if the XD + Sinevibes SVF completely negates the need for the OG, I'd rather know before buying either.

Outside of this main question, I was also looking for answers to the following:

XD

\-Does the XD's inability to bypass the digital FX circuit change the analogue sound compared to the OG?

\-Do the Sinevibe SVF filters make up for the lack of a 4-pole filter (that the OG had)

\-Does the XD really only have AD on the envelope generator, or is a full EG ADSR buried in a menu somewhere?

\-Does the XD's stereo output do true stereo when no FX are used, or is it dual mono?

​

OG

\-Does the OG's audio- make the incoming audio act as a waveform for synthesis, or does it just turn the keyboard into an FX pedal of sorts?

\-Does the OG go out of tune more frequently (or at all) compared to the XD?

\-Assuming you don't interact with the filter or resonance, do the OG and XD sound identical from a starting, INIT patch (i.e. oscillator quality, timbre, output etc)

​

SUPER SUPER super appreciate any responses, especially from owners of both devices.

— 0