RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/synthesizers • … • u/mister_drgn

Considering first hardware synth purchase (warning: long post)

For the past several months, I've been exploring synthesis, sound design, and music production from a very casual, non-professional perspective (I can't particularly play a keyboard, yeah I should work on that). So far, I've invested a fair amount in an iPad setup, include a lot of apps and a Keystep 37 (I also have a Qunexus I was gifted). It's all fun. But I've recently started exploring physical synth hardware options pretty obsessively. I don't need a hardware synth (there's some much you can do on iPad), and I'm not in a hurry to get one, particularly as I know getting one leads to wanting to get more. But it's fun to explore that world, and I like to overanalyze. So here are some thoughts, and I'd love to hear people's feedback...

Because I already have a mobile, software-based setup, the big question is what types of hardware would actually provide something new. I've been thinking about this with a couple constraints: a) I strongly prefer compact hardware, as I currently have a very small but comfortable space set up, b) I'm giving myself a budget of $1000 (fairly arbitrary, I have the disposable income, but I'm in no hurry to spend money). With that in mind, to add something beyond what I have now, I'd like to find hardware that 1) Provides a new and appealing physical interface. I'm not necessarily looking for "knob per function." My favorite interface that I've seen is the Hydrasynth, with shallow, context-specific menus and endless encoder knobs that provide visual feedback via the led rings. 2) Provides a new sound. The obvious idea here would be something analog. From what I've heard, I prefer rawer, 70s-style VCO sounds to smoother, 80s-style DCO sounds. But I'm still considering a lot of digital synths, if they can provide a decent sound. 3) Deep sound design with lots of modulation options. I want something I can really mess around with. This is an area where it's very hard for a hardware synth to compete with software options, of course.

With all that in mind, here are some ideas, starting with current favorite choice:

1) Dreadbox Typhon + maybe something else I really like the Typhon, and it's my top choice for an analog mono-synth. Super compact, great raw sound, deep modulation, and built-in effects. And I like the context-specific menus in theory, but I haven't had a chance to try one for myself. It's also cheap enough that I could perhaps get it with another compact synth. I'd want to get something that plays well with it and benefits from its effects. Right now, the Minifreak looks fun--it's difficult to argue that it adds a lot over iPad sound design, but it comes in a nice package, my kid could play with it, I can route audio to the Typhon for effects, etc. Other things I've considered to pair with the Typhon are the Behringer Proton, which is currently the semi-modular synth I'm finding the most interesting, but it means two monosynths, or a Nymphes, which sounds great but the interface seems terrible.

2) Hydrasynth (Desktop) I got a chance to try one this week, and it's as easy to use as I expected. Really just an awesome interface. This truly competes with software for ease of use and depth of sound design. But I hear a lot of concerns with people about the core sound, and about how it's hard to get anything warm out of it, despite its having multiple dedicated settings for this purpose, and I haven't heard sounds that I love in videos.

3) Multi/poly (Desktop) I only just started considering this one. It's an interesting contrast with the Hydrasynth. Seems to be easier to get a warm sound (that's kind of the point, right?), and its sound design is as deep as the Hydrasynth or deeper (and it has custom wavetables, which btw the Minifreak has too, unlike the Hydrasynth). But the interface feels noticeable worse than the Hydrasynth. Like, not terrible. It has context-specific menus, which I like. But worse. You don't have those 8 dedicated knobs, so there's a lot more of using the arrow buttons to switch between options.

4) Fourm I think this is my favorite analogy polysynth that I've looked at. Sounds great. Has a generally solid interface (though I wish it gave visual feedback when you're turning knobs). The modulation options are more limited than just about anything else I'm considering, but the modulation is really easy to configure, and it's not too bad (way better than the Korg Minilogue, for example). And the modulation is very well connected to poly aftertouch and the mod wheel, so this seems like a great synth for performance, not that I'm good enough to perform. Really my biggest problem here is that it's big, with no desktop option. Also it's lacking in built-in effects, so I'd have to invest in something else. More realistically I can just run it through the iPad for effects, but with my current setup I don't have great table space for both this and the iPad together.

5) Digitone 2 This represents kind of a different direction. Again, I like the interface with context-specific menus and endless encoders (I've played with a digitakt), and I find elektron sequencing very cool (I know I haven't mentioned sequencing at all before here). But I have Drambo on iPad which replicates elektron sequencing really well while providing \_many\_ more features. I don't really need a hardware groovebox. And again, it looks like it's difficult get warmish sounds out of the different synthesizer options. Still, the form factor and physical interface here is appealing.

I guess that's enough. Thanks to anyone who has the patience to read all this.

— 0