RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/synthesizers • … • u/alibloomdido

Thoughts on Carbon firmware on Cobalts and Argons

Not a user of any of Modal synths but I have a lot of respect for them. Recently saw that post about running Carbon firmware with additional oscillators from Cobalt on Argon, was super excited, asked about running the same firmware on Modal's newer and cheaper Element 1 which is basically Cobalt with fewer knobs.

But then I started thinking about Modal being not a very rich company - many of you remember how not so long ago they were struggling financially, when you could only download the recent firmware from their Facebook page, then being bought by some investor (from Hong Kong or Taiwan?). They are probably lucky to even still be in business.

And their synths are very interesting and quite unique in the best way - very good sound, a ton of interesting sound design capabilities. Plus good keybeds, sturdy well designed chassis and editor software for several platforms. They clearly put a lot of love and effort into their synths and think about making user experience really good while keeping the synths relatively affordable. And now anyone can install the firmware from Carbon, their more expensive and more recent "experimental" synth, into some used Cobalt or Argon. Not saying it's bad to make such custom firmware but a bit concerned about the future of the company which I think is important for the whole synth thing we're interested in.

The question is what the strategy should be for such companies in this new situation.

Make super premium 5 octave versions with poly AT, touch strip, more knobs, X-Y controller in addition to mod/pitch wheels?

Open their code and invite vibe coders to make new firmware and then test and curate the best?

Embrace social media, run sound design and tutorial video contests?

Try to get additional revenue streams by selling patch collections from their website?

Try to design new synths with really good UI tailored for the new sound engines?

Probably all these options together would work but each one requires some resources and budgets.

What do you think? I'm really sympathetic to Modal and don't want them to go out of business. Or is this new custom firmware practice (which isn't going anywhere) not really threatening their business model? What do you think?

— 0