What makes a game... fun?
I'm currently working on 2 games and they both play pretty clean with a decent mix of luck and strategy, but they both feel a little dull. One of the games I was able to make some changes and it improved, but could still use some work. The other game is still pretty dull, but I love the mechanics. Without going into specifics on these two particular projects, I would like to get the community's thoughts on what makes a game fun.
How do games get players emotionally involved?
What elements build excitement as the game progresses?
What makes a player finish a game and immediately say "let's play again!"?
I look forward to your thoughts and examples! Thanks
.
Edit:
Thanks for the responses! I've collected a bunch of the comments and am loosely categorizing them under "Interesting Decisions", "User Experience" and "Tension" even though many of these could fit in all three categories.
Interesting Decisions:
- Rewards and Consequences
- Subverted Expectations
- Spectacular Combinations
- Learning/Skill Development
- Identification (seeing yourself in the 'story')
- Variety (each replay is unique)
- Ability to improve with more play (skill)
- Using strategy to manage luck
- Wanting to try something different next playthrough
User Experience:
- Amount of Information (Full, Semi, Everchanging)
- "Dead Air" (waiting for your turn) sucks
- Social Interaction
- Good Visuals
- Good Theme
- Building/Creating/Doing something you're proud of
- Length of Game: 20-30min games get multiple replays
Tension:
- Increasing Power/Abilities/Choices
- End game before negative emotions set in
- Desired Outcome and uncertainty of getting it
- Upping the ante/ acceleration throughout the game
- Not knowing who is going to win
- Changing who is in the lead
- Luck changing your options, not deciding the game
- Working towards mini-goals
And here were some examples mentioned:
- Roulette – great tension due to stakes, zero strategy
- Chess – Full information
- MTG – Partial information
- Uno – Rapidly changing information
- Monopoly – Decided too early and then a long waiting for it to be over
- Scrabble – Different every time. Good back and forth scoring, luck and strategy
- Pandemic Legacy – User Experience
- Red Dragon Inn – Huge, rare combos add excitement to the game. Player targeting keeps it from breaking game.
- Risk – Great game, but if 4-5 people are playing, there is too much down time
- Carcassonne – Early game didn’t have great visuals