The Jax Gender Problem (Ep 9 Spoilers)
Alright. I don't normally make posts but I feel this discussion has reached a point where I have to voice my opinion on the matter. All I ask is that people keep things civil as I am about to say some things that might ruffle some jammies.
Is Jax trans? Yes or no?
If you were to ask me, I'd say it's a bit of both. I'll get into why in a moment. But let me be clear, there is outright evidence that supports Jax being transgender, but it's the same with JAx not being transgender.
I've seen lots of discussion about Jax's gender identity, and how people relate to it, and I want to get all of this out there because I feel a lot of takes are being reductive and unhelpful to the conversation at hand. There are people who present opposing ideas, and the other camps of interpretation get fussy about how their interpretation HAS to be right.
I am an amateur author, (AMATEUR, take what I say with a grain of salt, but be sure to read what I'm saying) I don't claim to know everything about media but I think it's safe to assume that I'm a little more media literate than the average person, and I look at media in a different way than the average consumer. This is important to my side of this conversation. It gives me a different perspective of looking at how a story is told. So, now I'm going to get into the weeds and stop dancing around the topic.
Jax being transgender is a completely valid interpretation. It is highly hinted at in the text and is one of many valid interpretations of the character. But, I feel a lot of the arguments are reductive of the actual conversation at hand. People disagree with this take, and get called transphobic which isn't productive at all. The theory that Jax could be genderqueer of any variety is also valid. But this isn't just about Jax being trans, I feel it's part of a larger problem that I want to get into as a nonbinary person, which, as some of you may know, has me falling under the trans umbrella.
The interpretation that Jax is a cisgender man who struggles with toxic masculinity is JUST AS VALID. There is much evidence that supports this side as well. One I keep seeing is that Leeroy Mateo still goes by He/Him in the real world. I will accept that this is flimsy as the journey to discovering your gender identity is often long and arduous, it took me three or four years to figure out I wasn't transfem, cis, or agender, just something in between.
But there's an issue I've been taking with this conversation as a whole when it comes to the idea that Jax being transgender is the only valid interpretation of the media. For one, it's extremely dismissive of other takes. But my biggest gripe is that it reduces men who like feminine things to having to be transgender, no matter what. It's the same thing as "Oh, you're a man and you like wearing makeup to look nice? You must be GAY." Not that being gay is bad, mind you, but it's very invalidating of heterosexual men who like to pretty up. Jax's feminine traits which he has pushed deep down in some variety of toxic masculinity doesn't mean he's transgender. He hides those parts of himself because he feels they're not manly enough, but he doesn't want to admit he likes cutesy things, he doesn't want to admit that a dress can be pretty on a man, because that feels very un-manly. But what happens when you take these feminine traits and compress it down to "You must be a woman, actually." What of cis men, who like feminine things? They're not transgender because of that part of themselves. Part of healthy gender identity is being comfortable with going against the gender norm. A man who cries isn't gay or trans, he's just somebody in touch with his emotions. It's the same with Jax.
Now, I want to touch on the authorial side of things a little bit. A lot of people say that if Goose wanted it to be explicit she would have outright said it but I feel it's missing a larger part of storytelling that I might be able to touch on. If you only have a trail of breadcrumbs, then all you've got is a faint idea of what's trying to be communicated. If I said, "I like loud music," (bear with me here) it could mean myriad things. It could mean loud gangster rap, it could be heavy metal, it could be screamo. There's a lot of things that I could mean by that. But if I were to say something like "I like overdriven electric guitars" that narrows it down to a genre, metal.
The interpretation that Jax is transgender is an interpretation left to us by breadcrumbs. Why is it only breadcrumbs, why is it only a trail of clues and hints? Because the author wanted it to be open to interpretation. There would have been something more concrete, more solid than a scene where Jax blushes with a bow on his head, with "Isn't she beautiful" playing, with his past and dealing with toxic masculinity. It doesn't have to be Goose saying "Jax is transgender," or anything extremely explicit, it has to be something that holds more water than something you could apply to another interpretation. Back to my music analogy, it's like saying "How did you not know I only like death metal! I said I like loud music!" Like, there was a lot left up to interpretation there. I feel we're getting lost in the sea of labels and identity and forgetting the main draw about Jax, which is who he is as a CHARACTER.
When it comes down to it, Jax's core character conflict is his struggle with toxic masculinity that he developed under his mother's abuse. That much is something we can agree on, hopefully. Jax being transgender is just as valid, as dealing with that toxic masculinity is part of that journey, but it's also part of the journey of becoming comfortable with manhood as a cis man. I want to make one thing abundantly clear, however. Jax can be transgender, that is something heavily implied by the text and hinted at a lot, but it's not the only valid interpretation of his character because the thing with media is that it's about interpretation. How you connect with a character and their struggles is far more important than whether or not a character is transgender.
What we are given is left ambiguous and it's not just because of the reasons you think. I do find this decision to be deliberate. We don't see the end of that arc, we don't see the conclusion that Leeroy comes to in his real life. This is important, because seeing who he is in real life adds credence to the idea that he's just a cis man struggling with toxic masculinity. He very well could be closeted. But there is a lot left up to interpretation and we are left to fill in the blanks ourselves. I think that Goose wanted there to be a discussion, but I don't think it's helpful to get angry at the other side for disagreeing, that's what discussion is all about.
And when it comes to media, I want to make my stance very clear. It's about interpretation. All of it is. The meaning you find in art is the only correct meaning. You can look at a painting and say that it makes you feel sad, that the colours and shapes and shading feel like an allegory for your specific experiences and struggles. But just because somebody else sees it and says it makes them happy because they see it differently, that they see a triumph over their own struggles that are different yet similar to yours doesn't mean that they just don't get it. Not allowing the other side to have a voice is not getting it.
And I get it, you see yourself and your journey in the character. That's beautiful and it's what this show does beautifully. The characters all feel very real and we have amazing representation for our genderqueer folks in Zooble and Ribbit. Your interpretation is valid and your gender is something to wear with pride. But just because somebody disagrees and finds a different meaning in the character arcs we are presented with, doesn't mean they are transphobic. However, looking at the evidence that point to Jax being trans and saying "Uh, no, there's nothing there at all" is problematic.
My main point here is, after meandering around a bit, do not discount other interpretations because of your feelings. I get that the whole transgender thing right now is a tense topic and the political climate in some places is shifting in favour of our LITERAL death, but it's not grounds to look at people who are OUR ALLIES and pushing them away because they don't agree on topics of media discussion. Calling everyone who disagrees a transphobe will only fuel the fire that is burning us all. I think I've gotten everything I wanted to say out, I get that this is all very rambly, but I needed to get this out there and I had a few things I wanted to say.