Guaranteed partnership payments for capital
If some experts would pity me here, I would greatly appreciate it. I have a question about guaranteed payments from a partnership for use of a partner's capital, which from my research seem [confusing at best](https://www.gibsondunn.com/wp-content/uploads/documents/publications/Kreisberg-GuaranteedPaymentsforCapital.pdf).
Moderately simplified hypothetical to get at my question:
I have contributed $1,000 to ABC Partnership, and in return I receive a distribution of $25 per quarter regardless of ABC's net income (in addition to a $1,000 liquidation preference in ABC). My 2022 Schedule K-1 shows $100 in Box 4b, the instructions for which say to report this amount on Schedule E (Form 1040), line 28, column (k).
Obviously this is income to me that should be taxed at ordinary rates. My questions are:
* I have an identical arrangement with XYZ Partnership, but they report the $100 in Box 5 of Schedule K-1 as interest income. Is ABC or XYZ demonstrably wrong, or do they just have tax professionals with different opinions on an unclear matter? * The income from ABC will be included on Form 8960, line 4a for the NIIT. Even though column (k) of Schedule E is called "Nonpassive income", I don't materially participate in the partnership within the definition of 469(h). Is this income subject to the NIIT, and therefore **not** subtracted on line 4b of Form 8960? I assume yes, at which point the tax treatment is identical to interest income anyway.
For bonus points, I had the same arrangement with DEF Partnership also, which converted to a Caymanian corporation taxed as a PFIC. I actually think this one is fairly straightforward - if I make a Section 1295 (QEF) election, the pass-through income of the PFIC should equal the distribution amount.
* Despite the guaranteed nature of the payment, the company's QEF report shows some capital gain - this now passes through at qualified rates, right? * The ordinary component of the pass-through is subject to the NIIT and captured on line 6 of Form 8960, right? * Are there any timing concerns around when distributions are made, or are QEF distributions always a nontaxable basis adjustment? * The QEF election seems like the obvious choice, right?