RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tax • … • u/HatterJack

What to do about an employer that refuses to withhold federal taxes from payroll?

Hey Reddit, back in February, my partner began working for a company that has an accountant whose payroll practices seem to be a bit shady, and I believe is setting my partner up for a huge financial burden come next tax day.

Since being hired on, the company has not withheld any federal taxes at all, and seems to not be withholding enough for state taxes. When asked about it, management has repeatedly stated that they aren’t withholding federal taxes because they overpaid on employment taxes last year, as a result of overpaying another employee.

It seems obvious to me that, come next tax season, my partner is going to be stuck with a massive tax bill as a result of her employer (ultimately, whatever their accountant does while in their employ, short of embezzlement, is their responsibility to correct, isn’t it?), but the owners of the business have repeatedly assured her that there will be no such tax burden, because the taxes that should be coming out of her paychecks are offset by the overpayment of another employee’s taxes, which gave them a tax credit.

I have never come across anything even remotely like this before, and it smells pretty fishy to me. What do you think, Reddit? And what can my partner do to protect herself from what I expect to be an astronomical tax bill at the end of the year?

For reference, we live in the United States, in Oregon, so I understand that our situation may translate differently in other places.

— 0