How are preparers or "my tax guy" getting W-2 filers massive refunds?
I do our taxes myself with tax software, and as a dual income family we always end up owing a bit, especially now that we can't deduct NY property taxes over $10K anymore. But every year as I file and pay, I hear all sorts of people telling me about their "tax guy" who gets them refunds big enough to put down payments on cars. These are non-business-owners, making regular W-2 income and other fully reported-to-the-IRS income on stuff like stock sales and interest.
Is this just people overwithholding and not understanding how the tax system works, getting taken advantage of by the tax guy? If both of us withheld at the single rate and added more on top, sure we'd get a huge refund but obviously that's nothing the tax guy can influence. I can only think of 2 things a normal W-2 taxpayer/their preparer can do:
- Make so many charitable donations that you can itemize again, like tithing 10%+ of your income to your church...IRS has to allow for that, and maybe that's one of the limits they cut it off at to account for religious taxpayers, who knows? - Make up business income/losses against income. Small business owners already funnel all their personal expenses through the business so I guess it wouldn't be.a stretch for a shady tax guy to ask you what you spent on basically everything that year and put it down as expenses.
It sounds stupid to ask, but are preparers privy to the limits they can stretch stuff like that and not trigger an audit? I know that super-wealthy taxpayers have access to tax shelters and financial instruments designed purposely to skirt regulations and be just barely legal, but those wouldn't be in reach of standard wage-earners. I'm just interested to see if thee folks' tax guys just invented a business for them out of thin air that conveniently loses money...and if they end up getting in trouble for it. It just seems to be one of these security-by-obsurity situations where the vast majority of taxpayers just use TurboTax/understand the mechanics but there's a whole other letter vs. spirit of the law thing going on.