RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tax • … • u/sorator

Uncertain of a prior year nondeductible tradIRA contribution, now taking RMDs

Curious if any of y'all have any ideas beyond what I've already tried in this situation.

A family member accidentally made a nondeductible contribution to their tradIRA years ago. They realized it in time to list it as nondeductible and file form 8606, but they didn't think to undo the contribution. They don't remember for sure which year it was, but we *think* it was 2015 or 2011.

In 2024, they started taking their RMDs from that account. Part of the distribution is a return of that nondeductible contribution, so part of it is nontaxable. But we don't know for sure which year it was contributed.

We tried talking to the account custodian, but they don't keep records of deductible vs nondeductible contributions. We've sent in form 4506 to ask for a photocopy of the 2015 return, which we think was the year it occurred; if it was, and we get that copy, then we should be fine. Otherwise, I'm inclined to say the year it was contributed isn't all that important if we can be fairly confident in the *amount* contributed, and tell my software it was in 2015 even if we aren't certain that's correct.

(We filed 2024 timely and plan to just file an amendment to claim the small refund once we get this straightened out.)

* Am I right in thinking the actual year of the nondeductible contribution doesn't actually impact the pro-rata calculation? * If I'm wrong, any other ideas for how we could pin down what year it was? * Any other thoughts?

Thanks, friends!

— 0