Withholding Taxes from tIRA to Roth conversions followed by Indirect Roth conversion
We are planning to pay our taxes for this year by withholding them from a Roth conversion from my traditional IRA. As step 2, I would like to make an indirect Roth conversion by depositing into the Roth a check in the same amount that was withheld from the Roth conversion. Step 2 will make the Roth conversion, in essence, whole. I understand that this technique is not for everyone, but in our personal circumstances this year, it appears to be the best option for us.
My retirement accounts are at Fidelity. I have recently learned that the way Fidelity reports these transactions to the IRS may be problematic. I am hoping people here can help us better understand these issues.
It has been reported in various places that for these types of transactions, Fidelity has a system default whereby Fidelity issues a Form 5498 with Box 2 checked, rather than Box 3. As I understand it, this is not correct. Box 3 should be checked.
Apparently, Fidelity’s stance is that after the indirect conversion check is deposited and processed, the Fidelity customer may specially request an “exception” from a retirement service representative to recode the transaction to Box 3. However, this is not guaranteed and there are reports that Fidelity has refused to grant the exception in some instances. If you are refused, presumably you are stuck with Box 2.
I am unclear on the consequences of Form 5498 with Box 2 checked versus Box 3. Are there any circumstances where there will be no adverse complications or consequences if Box 2 is checked? For example, if we both are over 59 ½, does it matter?
Fidelity itself has been less than illuminating on these issues and I would be grateful for any assistance this group can give us. We are recently retired and find we have all kinds of new things to learn in this new world.