RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tax • … • u/osirhc

Live in PA and work in MD - question about seemingly incorrect W2

I live in PA and my day job is also in PA, but I have a side gig in MD. The W2 from my MD employer lists the locality/county tax in box 17, which is the box for MD state tax. Box 19, which is for locality/county tax, is blank. Verifying from my paystub YTD info - it seems what's entered in box 17/MD state tax is actually the locality/county tax.

This seems incorrect, as I'm MD state tax exempt due to being a PA resident and not having a place of abode in MD (MW507, number 5). Local/county tax is being withheld properly from my check, and PA state tax is being properly withheld from my check.

The other potentially strange thing is that my wages from box 1 are listed twice in box 16 (once for PA, and again for MD).

This is where I run into problems, because when I enter my W2 info as it's written into TurboTax, TurboTax tells me I owe to PA. The value it tells me I owe is the same value listed in box 17, which is the same value verified with my paystub YTD that has already been withheld. Additionally, it tells me MD owes me a refund. The value it tells me MD owes me is the same value entered in box 17 for MD state tax/the same value that I verified with my paystub YTD as the local/county tax that has been correctly withheld.

My employer's HR department insists that my W2 is correct, that MD locality/county tax is combined with MD state tax, and placed in the state tax box - based on "federal guidelines" - which I don't feel confident in, because why would the federal government impose guidelines on how to collect state and local taxes?

Does my employer need to give an amended W2 that omits MD wages for box 16, and the incorrect value for box 17? Is anyone familiar with working in MD, but living in PA, that might be able to tell me if I'm on the right track with my thinking?

Lastly, because this is super long already - I had this same issue in 2023 and 2024, but due to life circumstances, I couldn't do a deep dive into the problem. I ended up paying what TurboTax told me to pay (I don't know why, but for some reason, the last two years it told me I owed PA and MD, vs this year where it tell me MD owes me).

— 0