RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tax • … • u/HulksInvinciblePants

'Home Mortgage Interest Deduction' with two overlapping loans

In 2025, I temporarily carried two mortgages. Basically, contingent offers don't work in my area, so I was forced to buy before I could sell. I'm trying to calculate my mortgage interest deduction, using Publication 936. However, I'm running into some verbiage issues that could make or break my "average mortgage balance." I get the best result with the first calculation method (Avg First/Last):

Month/Avg| Loan 1| Loan 2 ---|---|----|---- Jan 1 Balance| X| 0 Dec 31 Balance | 0| Y Average | (X+0)/2| (0+Y)/2

Add the two averages and there's my best number.

However, there are two listed stipulations that are not clear.

> 1. You didn't borrow any new amounts on the mortgage during the year. (This doesn't include borrowing the original mortgage amount.)

> 2. You didn't prepay more than 1 month's principal during the year. (This includes prepayment by refinancing your home or by applying proceeds from its sale.)

Based on my understanding, a 'new' loan should not count as borrowing 'new amounts' on an existing loan. Also, a loan payoff should not count as prepaying a loan as its a separate process entirely.

I feel like I'm in the clear with this method, but I'm not sure if there's precedent I need to be aware of. The limits seem to lack specifics like tax-loss harvesting and what defines "substantially identical" securities.

— 0