HYPO: COD + Seller-financed + Purchase Money + Price-adjustment OR Part-Gift/Part-Sale?
Dad bought a $20,000 car and transferred it to his son Sam, who agreed to pay Dad back in installments of $1,000 per month. \[After Sam lost his job and could not make the payments,\] Dad, feeling sorry for Sam, told him he would only have to pay $15,000 \[waiving the last $5,000\]. Would you characterize the following as a part-gift/part-sale? OR COD subject to a price reduction? OR something else entirely?
Alternatively,
John bought a tractor worth $20,000 from his friend Joe two years ago. Joe allowed John to cover the cost of the tractor by making twenty equal payments of $1,000 each month. After he made the third payment, John lost his farming job and remained unemployed for 6 months. Because he did not ever expect to recover all that he was owed, Joe agreed to waive the remaining payments. If Burt were neither insolvent nor in bankruptcy proceedings, Sam’s gesture would cause Burt to have? Similarly, would you characterize the following as a part-gift/part-sale? OR COD subject to a price reduction? OR something else entirely?
Is there a difference between these two hypos?