Was Aroa's Requiem a mistake?
From a writing point of view, do you think TM has made life harder for himself by introducing Aroa's Requiem?
And I'm not talking about the endless theories about Arthur unlocking the full power of the rune, imo it's pretty clear he won't reach that level, if he progresses at all with his understanding of it.
There have been two occasions where the question "why doesn't he use Aroa's Requiem?" came to my mind. First, in the snowy zone, when Caera's dimension ring is broken, and second in the chapter before the most recent, when he's speaking with the djinn but the crystal is failing.
In both cases he doesn't try to repair the item in question nor does he mention that he knows he can't, he just seems to forget that he has that ability. He would definetly benefit from the item being repaired; Caera almost dies from frostbite and starvation because they don't have access to her stuff and he surely would learn more from training and speaking more with the djinn.
The reason why it's not even mentioned seems clear to me; TM just didn't think about it. Having a plot hole here and there is not the end of the world; the amount of people involved in writing and checking what is published dwarfs when compared to the readers, who will often notice plot holes even in solidly written stories, and these aren't big slip ups that completely invalidate the plot.
What I'm worried about is that there will be more of these situations in the future, where TM will write some situation or adversity involving any object not working and the question of "Can't he just use Aroa's Requiem?" will pop up.
And while it's true that right now it's easy to dismiss the two examples I mentioned by saying "we don't know the exact limits of this abilty", this is something that will gradually fade away as he uses it more and more. Let's look at how he's used it so far and what we learned from it:
​
* He used it in the mirror room, where we learned that he most likely can't turn back organic objects * He used it on the portal, where we learned that he probably needs the original parts of the object he's trying to reconstruct, and that he doesn't need to understand how the item works to repair it * He used it to repair the security mechanism at the reliquiary, where we learned that it can be used to repair a mana-powered device * He used it to restore a dead relic, and we didn't learn anything new here.
​
The more we get examples of what he can and can't do with the relic, the more the possible explanations for why he didn't use it are disproven, even retroactively. Maybe he didn't repair the ring because he can only repair aether stuff? Well, he repaired the security mechanisms. Maybe he didn't repair the crystal because he doesn't understand how it's made? Well, he repaired the portal and the dead relic.
In the end this will bring us to a situation where either TM doesn't think about it/just ignores it and it remains as a "maybe there's an explanation but it just looks like a plot hole" thing, or he defines precisely what the rune can and can't do (even if he doesn't tell us explicitly) and in every situation thinks about whether Arthur can "cheese" this problem with Aroa's Requiem, and if the answer is "yes", changes something about it.
Either way, it seems to me like he's sort of writing himself in a corner, and while I agree that it's a nice power that opens up a lot of possibilities (I really liked how he used it for the heist, and the fact that he can revive dead relics as well) instead of just a brute-force power level increase, it also creates a lot of problems for the future.