RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tbatenovel • … • u/Rugenio

Arthur vs Taci: a fair 1vs1 breakdown

I know this is a few weeks late in terms of the most recent chapter but bear with me.

I've seen many comments that, when trying to evaluate Arthur's level at the time of the fight with Taci in terms of Asuras, said that he only won because he had a huge terrain advantage, aka the aether zone or whatever you want to call it.

So I will break down the fight and their abilities to try to disprove this and show that Arthur would win even in a fair 1v1.

First off, let's list off all the nerfs and buffs the characters had:

Taci

Nerfs:

1a) No ambient mana for spells

2a) Can't refill core with mana from atmosphere

3a) Little solid ground for Mirage Step (esp. at the beginning)

Buffs:

Nothing really.

Arthur

Nerfs:

1b) NO REGIS

2b) No destruction (a consequence of 1b but still a separate thing)

3b) Very little solid ground for Burst Step (esp. at the beginning)

4b) Couldn't use God Step outside the Relictombs area

Buffs:

5b) Infinite Aether

6b) Much faster regeneration

7b) Easier to get "insight", unlocks new abilities fast.

So how influential are those?

First off, what spells using ambient mana did Taci use? Nothing that we've seen. The only "ambient mana" spell he used was against the lances, where he broke down their spells and absorbed them, which would be useless against Arthur anyway. Maybe he has spells he didn't show but Pantheons really seem the "augmenters" of the Asura races.

2a) is only relevant if Taci knows mana rotation as he won't be meditating mid fight. We don't know if all Asuras know it, or only Dragons or just Sylvia. It's reasonable to assume he does; however mana rotation can only prolong the time you can fight, it can't sustain you fully.

3a) is equally as bad for him and Arthur; rather it's worse on Arthur because Taci can still fly even without solid support

So overall he didn't get nerfed much.

1b) is pretty big, as shown in the fight with Cadell Regis can hold his own against strong opponents when going all out.

2b) is significant if Arthur is willing to die after killing him or has something to vent the Aether on after. We can assume Destruction is a no-no and count this as irrelevant.

3b and 4b (and realizing that he had been "nerfed") are the main reasons he took a lot of damage in the first blows after entering the aether zone.

5b and 6b look like the biggest buff and they certainly help, but in the end it only means that Arthur *cannot lose* as long as he doesn't die in one hit, not that he can win. If the fight had ended with Arthur not landing any significant damage on Taci and just winning by exausthion I'd agree that he won because of the environment, but that wasn't even a viable strat or he'd be stuck in the aether realm for eternity.

Finally, 7a doesn't really matter. He temporarily unlocks the ability to make platforms, which only balances out 3b, then after having already cut three arms from Taci learns how to "fly" but the fight is already over. The only other thing he learns to do is to God Step without having to follow the paths but that as well is just for the finishing blow.

So, with all that in mind, why do I think Arthur would still win a fair 1v1?

Because the only moment when they were fighting at full power, without many nerfs or buffs, was after Taci had transformed, and the result of that was Taci losing half his arms. Even then it was without Regis.

Sure, without infinite aether he might have exausthed it earlier in order to heal, but at the same time most of the damage he took was because he was discovering the effects of the aether zone and couldn't god step. Even before they jumped into the portal, when he had to restrain himself because of the bystanders, he didn't take serious damage, and that's without the Djinn armor.

It is true though that Arthur is a bad matchup for Taci in general, both because he doesn't use mana so the spear and the "spell-breaking" spell are useless against him, and because both are "augmenters" but Arthur has better mobility and some mid range attacks.

Overall the combo Arthur+Regis would beat Taci almost every time, and if destruction was allowed it wouldn't even be a contest. I assume the recent return of Realmheart doesn't change much for this specific fight; however it would surely make his life easier against a caster-focused opponent of the same strength.

Now the big question is where Taci stands in regard to adult Asuras. I don't believe he's as strong as a fully trained adult soldier but would put him above civilian, non-fighter Asuras (if they even exist). Yes, he's a genius, aether orb, personal training and so on, but he's 14 compared to creatures that have lived and trained for centuries if not millennias. Probably a low tier Asura in strength overall.

— 0